Jack Balkin has written 'a book about how people use history when they interpret the Constitution' (3). What he has not attempted to do is write a book about how people use history when they interpret a constitution. His use of the definite article makes clear that it is a specific constitutional document that is the object of his scholarly inquiry. A work that has been reviewed extensively, Balkin's book has been widely and rightly acclaimed for its nuanced treatment of interpretive issues central to American constitutional theorising. One of the challenges for his readers is to shift the focus to the indefinite article, to explore the implications of his analysis for comparative constitutional theory, which is to say, how the uses and abuses of 'memory and authority' might be viewed in constitutional settings very different from the circumstances that have come to define the Constitution in the United States.
Memory and Authority is both a distillation of ideas that the author has grappled with in previous writing, as well as a further elaboration that broadens the inquiry into a specific interpretive modality - originalism - to a more general consideration of the manner in which history is invoked in constitutional contestation to achieve desirable results in the present. Thus, 'arguments about ethos, tradition, and honoured authority are always as much about present-day values as they are about history' (53). As the leading academic proponent of 'framework' or 'living originalism' (the argument that an original governing framework enables constitutional construction to keep the document up to date), Balkin sees in the interpretive resources it provides for ‘build[ing] out and implement[ing] the Constitution under changing circumstances' (99) a conclusive reason for preferring it over the 'thick originalism' that has emerged as the governing jurisprudential proclivity of today's conservative judges and scholars. As for its reach and relevance for jurisdictions outside the United States, ‘living originalism is fairly easy to adapt to other countries with a written constitution' (76). By way of contrast, originalism [as practiced by the conservatives] ... has not taken hold in many other places' (75).
Unlike previous reviewers of his work, who are aligned with the author in their US-centric perspective, and who therefore consider the strengths, weaknesses, and political biases of Balkin's account of originalism with that in mind, the discussion here focuses on his intriguing but largely undeveloped thoughts concerning memory and authority in other places. Do the reasons for originalism's comfortable fit within the American constitutional context provide any insight into the ways in which it has played out elsewhere? Specifically, Balkin […]
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671642
Search
06 November 2026
BOOK REVIEW: Gary Jeffrey JACOBSOHN, Memory and authority: the uses of history in constitutional interpretation, by Jack M. BALKIN (New Haven/London: Yale University Press, 2024)(Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 181-187)
30 October 2026
BOOK REVIEW: Giulio ABBATE, Legal education in the western world: a cultural and comparative history, by Rogelio PÉREZ-PERDOMO (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2024) (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 174-180)
Rogelio Pérez-Perdomo's work provides a comparative and historical account of legal education in the Western world, from ancient Rome to the present day. Following the traditional division of comparative law, it addresses both the civil and common law traditions, focusing on changes in legal education over the centuries and the interrelations between the two traditions in contemporary times.
Adopting a longue durée perspective, the book presents itself as an 'introduction to a cultural and comparative history of the law' (1), and it achieves its purpose. Alongside the historical analysis of legal education through its main features, the book examines the interactions between legal education and its social and intellectual context, also focusing on 'the social role of the most important legal actors' (1) - legal professionals.
This work demonstrates that legal education is, and has always been, inseparable from the ideas and concepts of law, its historical development and its social function. Law possesses a constitutive social force.' It has been a factor in the ordering and disciplining of society. Legal education, in turn, 'is linked to the law as a way of ordering society and to the conceptualisation of the law itself' (1), playing a significant social role.
Pérez-Perdomo's work goes further, aiming to clarify the role of legal education in organising law and maintaining legal tradition. This methodological approach defines the first chapter of the book, which addresses the civil law tradition. The chapter's primary aim is to demonstrate the relationship between legal education and the conception of law, from classical Rome to Justinian. It outlines the gradual development of the legal field and the organisation of methods for legal knowledge and its transmission. These points are discussed particularly with reference to the opinions of the jurisconsults, which structured legal knowledge and contributed to the transformation of the legal field in response to the changing needs of Roman society. Legal education, in turn, reflected the prevailing concept of law. And 'once the law was consolidated as an intellectual discipline' (11), legal education subsequently assumed a more formal character.
The work then examines the changes that occurred under Justinian's rule. The promulgation of the Corpus Iuris Civilis significantly altered the concept of law, which became identified exclusively with the written document sanctioned by political authority. As a result, the author argues, law became detached from […]
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671641
23 October 2026
BOOK REVIEW: Marjorie CARVALHO DE SOUZA, Punishment, labour and the legitimation of power, eds. Adam S FAGBORE, Nabhojeet SEN and Katherine ROSCOE (Routledge: Abingdon, 2025) (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 169-172)
Punishment, Labour and the Legitimation of Power, edited by Adam S. Fagbore, Nabhojeet Sen, and Katherine Roscoe, is the second volume in the series Social History of Punishment and Labour Coercion, initially published by Amsterdam University Press and now under Routledge. The series intends to be a 'platform for expansive understandings' of both punishment and labour coercion. By 'expansive', the series editors mean the analysis of a broad range of forms of punishment, enforced either by state apparatuses or non-state actors, as well as a wide spectrum of labour regimes, from wage labour and enslavement to indenture, tribute, convict, or unpaid labour.
This collective volume reflects that ambition not only in its thematic range, which includes under the notion of 'punishment' practices such as imprisonment, branding, banishment, convict labour, debt bondage, and penal servitude, but also in its geographical and temporal coverage. Overall, it spans over five millennia across four continents, from ancient Mesopotamia to eighteenth-century Japan, China, and Mongolia, and from Merovingian Gaul to nineteenth-century Portuguese Africa.
A rich introductory essay by the volume's three editors provides the framing for these diverse themes, geographies, and temporalities. They establish theoretical unity via a ‘Trans-cultural and Trans-epochal Perspective on Labour Mobility,’ defining the term not only as the capacity to move but also as the mobilisation into coerced labour.
The essays are organised into three clearly defined analytical axes, each comprising three chapters, which together trace three distinct temporal arcs from antiquity to the contemporary period.
Part I examines the relationship between punishment and the production of labour relations, both in its role of sustaining existing labour regimes and also in generating new ones. It includes contributions that explore punishment as a means of facilitating well-known shifts between labour systems, such as the end of slavery in the Atlantic world, but also as a mechanism for managing the workforce in less familiar contexts of heightened labour demand, such as ancient Egypt.
It is from this latter historical context that the section opens, with Adam Simon Fagbore's study of Old and Middle Kingdom Egypt. This contribution examines the central government's attempts to immobilise personnel within protected royal and temple endowments through a broad range of punitive practices, which targeted not only field labourers but also local officials who failed to […]
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671638
20 October 2026
ONLINE SEMINAR: History and Law Seminar: Meet the editors of legal history journals (30 NOV, 4pm GMT)
Abstract:
Join Allison Tirres, Craig Green and David Schorr for a discussion about publishing research in law and history. This session offers an opportunity to hear editors’ perspectives on developing an article, choosing a journal and navigating submission, peer review and revisions. Whether you are preparing your first submission or developing your next publication, come along to ask questions and gain practical insights into the publishing process. Postgraduate researchers, early career scholars and colleagues at all career stages are welcome.
More information here.
(source: Dr Victoria Barnes)
16 October 2026
BOOK REVIEW: Milan KUHLI, Strafgesetzbücher der Zwischenkriegszeit, eds. Arnd KOCH and Martin LÖHNIG (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2024) (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 166-168)
This compilation, edited by Arnd Koch and Martin Löhnig, deals with criminal law discourses and legislation in the early twentieth century. It refers to the interwar period (Zwischenkriegszeit), the period between the two World Wars (1918- 39). However, it is obvious that this period of legal history can only be comprehended if a broader temporal context is considered. Therefore, some of the case studies comprised in the book reflect issues concerning historical development between the mid-nineteenth century (eg in the article by Marju Luts-Sootak and Marin Sedman on the legal situation in Estonia) and the 1960s (eg in Danuta Janicka's account about Poland). Except for one article written in English (by Luts-Sootak and Sedman), the compilation is in German.
What is not apparent from the title of the anthology is the fact that the book focuses on legislation and discourse in Central and Eastern Europe. So, apart from an introductory article by Löhnig, the anthology comprises seven studies about the legal situation in individual territories in this European region. Attila Barna's article deals with the Hungarian criminal law, focussing on reform initiatives from 1908 and 1928. The latter reformed inter alia the system of fines and brought in the concept of the so-called serious criminal (Schwerverbrecher) which reflected discourses that could also be found in Germany during this time. Janicka's article deals with Poland, especially with the discussion about legal unification around 1918 and with the international network within which the debate took place. Furthermore, she shows the links to the concepts of the classical school of criminal law and to those of the sociological, 'modern' school. Koch addresses the history of Germany between 1919 and 1933, the so-called Weimar Republic. He notes that the project to comprehensively reform the German criminal code from 1871 (Reichsstrafgesetzbuch) failed during this period, but emphasises that the successes achieved in criminal policy during the Weimar period must not be forgotten. In this regard, Koch refers to the admission of women to the legal profession, the legislative regulation of fines, juvenile criminal law, and the reform of the prison system.
Luts-Sootak and Sedman focus on the Estonian Penal Code of 1929, which came into force in 1935. According to the authors [...]
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671636
10 October 2026
SEMINAR: Family Feud or Family Reunion? Comparative Law and Comparative Legal History as Siblings [Online: Comparative Legal History Dialogues Series, 15 OCT 2026]
The journal Comparative Legal History, published on behalf of the European Society for Comparative Legal History (ESCLH), is organizing an online seminar entitled “Family Feud or Family Reunion? Comparative Law and Comparative Legal History as Siblings”, as part of its Comparative Legal History Dialogues series. The event will take place on 15 October 2026, from 12:00 to 13:00 (CEST), via Zoom.
The seminar will bring together three distinguished scholars:
- Prof. Thomas Duve – Max Planck Institute for Legal History and Legal Theory;
- Prof. Ralf Michaels – Max Planck Institute for Comparative and International Private Law;
- Prof. Jaakko Husa – University of Helsinki.
Comparative law and comparative legal history share a close intellectual relationship. During the nineteenth century, when comparative law emerged as an autonomous discipline, comparative lawyers frequently engaged with legal history. However, following decades of increasing differentiation and specialization within legal scholarship, the relationship between these two fields invites renewed examination.
The discussion will explore whether comparative lawyers continue to engage with comparative legal history, the extent to which both disciplines share methodological approaches and theoretical assumptions, and how comparative legal historians might contribute to contemporary debates within comparative law.
Following brief contributions from the invited speakers, participants will have the opportunity to join an open discussion.
Participation is free and open to the public. Registration is required by email at: clhdialogues@gmail.com.
The organisers warmly invite scholars, researchers, and students interested in comparative law, legal history, and legal methodology to participate in this exchange.
09 October 2026
BOOK REVIEW: Panikos PANAYI, Legal responses to mass migration: from the nineteenth century to World War II, eds. Luigi NUZZO, Michele PIFFERI, Giuseppe SPECIALE and Cristina VANO (Abingdon: Routledge, 2025) (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 162-165)
This long, edited volume containing sixteen essays tries to address the question of legal responses to mass migration from the end of the nineteenth century until the post-Second World War period, an ambitious task. The editors, all Italian legal or legal history scholars, divide the volume into three sections covering 'Discourses', 'Policies and Institutions', and 'Legal Practices’; although the choice of location of the individual pieces is not always clear, especially in the case of those in sections 2 and 3. The chapters come from a 'collaborative research project on Legal History and Mass Migration' (xvi), focusing on the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Although the editors sought to take an interdisciplinary approach, most of the contributions are written by either legal scholars or legal historians. The main focus is Italy and the Italian diaspora, and most of the authors work in Italian universities.
Section I contains five chapters, beginning with Eliana Augusti's ‘From Vitoria to Kant: A Genealogy of ius migrandi’, an interesting philosophical-legal discussion about the concept of ius migrantis, traced through a series of philosophers down to the present. The author demonstrates command of the evolution of migration policy, and the essay is well conceptualised and clear in its explanation of the various authorities with which it engages, adding an interesting perspective on migration and migration law and rights. Chapter 2, by Giulio Abbate, on 'Emigration and Colonisation: The Debate in Italy at the End of the Nineteenth Century', tackles the issue of legal attitudes towards the relationship between emigration and colonisation, which initially focused upon emigration only taking place as a result of trade but gradually moved towards the idea that it could be linked to conquest because it would bring civilisation. Chapter 3, by Virginia Amorosi, on ‘Leaving Italy: Transoceanic Migration and Legal Discourse in the City of Napoli (1901-1910)’, despite its title and the fact that much of this essay focuses upon Naples, actually covers a wide range of discourse which falls under the broad description of 'legal', focusing not simply on Naples but also more broadly on Italy, including the concern about the loss of people as a result of emigration in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Chapter 4, by Francesco Rotondo, on 'The "Peculiar Paradox" of the Criminalisation of Italian Immigrants in Argentina in the Late Nineteenth Century' examines this process by focusing upon a series of individuals who concentrated up on perceived criminality and sickness against the background of a significant increase in the movement of people into Argentina at the end of the nineteenth century [...]
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671635
18 September 2026
BOOK REVIEW: Chiara VALSECCHI, Family and justice in the archives: historical perspectives on intimacy and the law, by Peter GOSSAGE and Lisa MOORE (ed.) (Montreal: Concordia University Press, 2024) (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 146-152)
Following the editors' introduction the volume gathers sixteen contributions (mostly unpublished), organised into five sections. These explore diverse aspects of the legal fields traditionally defined as family law and inheritance law, while more broadly extending to the realm of emotional and intimate relationships between individuals.
The editors have identified several thematic clusters around which the essays are grouped: 'Colonial Encounters' (four essays); 'Intergenerational Justice' (three essays); 'Intimacies in the Courtroom' (three essays); 'Marriage Regulation’ (three essays); and 'Everyday Violence' (three essays). The sixteen essays were written by scholars of different backgrounds and academic positions, based in diverse locations. The largest group consists of contributions concerning Canada, but the volume also includes studies on the United States, Australia, India, Latin America, and other regions of the world. Europe, too, is represented, with research on Britain, Russia, and France. Chronologically, the studies span two full centuries - the nineteenth and twentieth - offering a remarkable breadth of perspective both geographically and historically. This richness provides numerous insights for comparative reflection, even though comparison appears less straightforward from a strictly legal or normative standpoint, and proves more fruitful when pursued through broader, interdisciplinary perspectives.
From a general legal standpoint, it should be noted, for instance, that Fabienne Giuliani's study (Chapter 15), dedicated among other things to an 'extreme' social and legal figure - that of incestuous fathers in nineteenth-century France - represents, together with Juandrea Bates's work on Argentina (Chapter 6) and, to a lesser extent, certain analyses of Francophone Canada, a small minority of studies engaging directly with the codified systems of Civil Law countries. Indeed, while Europe's continental scholarship on family and personal law - often based on archival material such as private papers or judicial records - is already abundant, this very abundance makes the scope for technical legal comparison offered by the volume somewhat limited.
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671631
11 September 2026
BOOK REVIEW: James J. SHEEHAN, Shifting sovereignties: a global history of a concept in practice, by Moritz Mihatsch and Michael Mulligan [Berlin and Boston: Walther de Gruyter, 2025]; Sovereignty: European and global histories, 1400-1800, by Cornel Zwierlein and Daniel Lee [Leiden and Boston: Brill, 2025] (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 140-145)
On June 28, 2004, during a meeting of the NATO alliance in Istanbul, National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice slipped the following handwritten note to President George W Bush: 'Iraq is sovereign. Letter was passed from Bremer, 10.26 am Iraq time. Condi.' The president replied by writing in bold letters, 'Let Freedom Reign.' In retrospect, this exchange is one more example of the false hopes and genuine disappointments that attended the United States' misadventure in Iraq. It also shows just how elusive the concept of sovereignty turns out to be. After all, what could sovereignty possibly mean for Iraq in 2004, a state occupied by foreign troops and without a government that could control most of its divided and contested territory?
For more than a century, scholars have complained about the concept of sovereignty. Some thought it would eventually collapse under the weight of its own contradictions. In 1919, for example, Harold Laski wrote that 'when we examine the historic perspective of sovereignty, it becomes sufficiently obvious that its association with the modern state is no more than the expression of a particular environment which is already passing away.' Eight decades later, Hans Lindahl remarked that 'while not yet completely routed, the concept of sovereignty certainly seems on the retreat. Sovereignty, of course, has not passed away. Some observers remain convinced that it should. Jacques Maritain, for example, insisted in 1950 that political philosophy must eliminate sovereignty both as a word and as a concept.' More recently, in a book appropriately entitled Sovereignty RIP, legal scholar Don Herzog provided what might be called a […]
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2648456
04 September 2026
BOOK REVIEW: Paolo ASTORRI, The legal legacy of the reformation: Catholic and Protestant approaches to law, by John Duddington (ed.) [London and New York: Routledge, 2025] (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 137-139)
This volume collects essays presented at a conference organised by the editor in 2017 to mark the five-hundredth anniversary of the Reformation. Comprising thirteen chapters, the book is divided into four parts: (I Church Law and the Reformation; (LI) Catholic and Protestant Approaches to Law in the Life of the Church; (III) Catholic and Protestant Approaches to Church and State Law; and (IV) Catholic and Protestant Approaches to Particular Areas of Law.
The book situates itself in the wake of influential scholarship on law and the Reformation, including works by John Witte Jr (Law and Protestantism, 2002). Harold J Berman (Law and Revolution II, 2003), Mathias Schmoeckel (Das Recht der Reformation, 2014; Das Recht der Reformation in Frankreich, 2024), Martin Heckel (Martin Luthers Reformation und das Recht, 2016), and Robert von Friedeburg (Luther's Legacy, 2016), to mention only a few. As the editor notes in the preface, the core message of the book is that '500 years after it occurred the sundering of Christendom at the Reformation still resonates in the law, but equally the Reformation was not an isolated event. It was the product of forces in society that were present before Martin Luther nailed his theses to the church door at Wittenberg and to this extent the Reformation did not create change in all cases but instead recognised new forces at work in society and at times accelerated changes which, had the Reformation not occurred, might well have come about anyway' (xiii).
The volume is not fully homogeneous. Its contributions vary significantly in chronological scope, methodological approach, and confessional focus. Some chapters concentrate primarily on the early modern period, while others extend their analysis into the contemporary era. Some focus exclusively on Catholic ot Protestant contexts, while the majority attempt a comparative perspective. Inevi- tably, chapters that seek to offer broad overviews from the Reformation, or even from the late medieval period, can only provide succinct accounts, often relying more heavily on secondary literature than on primary sources. Nevertheless, the effort to connect early modern legal developments with contemporary legal frameworks is one of the book's notable strengths. As David Mclroy observes. 'the debates within and between the different strands of Christianity which emerged from the Reformation were a key factor in the development of legislation in respect of freedom of religion, civil rights and human rights'.
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671630
28 August 2026
BOOK REVIEW: Rosa CONGOST, From masters of slaves to lords of lands: the transformation of ownership in the western world, by James Q. Whitman [Cambridge: Cambrdige University Press, 2025] (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 131-136)
The book I review here is one that cannot fail to impress any reader interested in the historical evolution of property rights. This will be the case whether you are interested in the legal discourse around the concept of property, or in the real and material interests that may lie behind the discourse. In this review, I will emphasise the aspects of the book I find most interesting, while pointing out some questions that came to mind during my reading. I will highlight not only the most obvious findings, but also the possibilities the book offers for starting a dialogue with historians who, like me, are working on similar topics, albeit from different angles and perspectives.
This dialogue is facilitated by the author's ability to link the multiple references and quotations he provides from classic works, with which we are all familiar, with research from a wide variety of specialised fields. This is evident from the outset. Hence, Blackstone's statement that starts the introduction: ‘[t]here is nothing which so generally strikes the imagination, and engages the affections of mankind as the right of property, which allows the author to present his book as being about 'legal imagination’; an imagination, he immediately clarifies, that is expressed through the 'idioms of power' (10), a concept taken from Orlando Patterson's book Slavery and Social Death.' James Whitman shares one of the central theses of this book, which is the idea that the modern conception of property has its origins in a slave society. This is an idea that in itself already establishes a dialogue with the modern period, especially in a country such as the United States, which had to wait until the second half of the nineteenth century for the definitive triumph of the 'free-soil doctrines' and the 'disappearance of lawful slavery'. This reference locates us in the contemporary Common Law legal tradition where we are reminded that the success of the 'castle doctrine' and the homestead exemption proves the strong identification of property with land, an idea that is widespread throughout the Western world. To this effect, dialogue between scholars of different legal traditions is guaranteed from the outset because 'the West, as I [the book's author] will speak of it in this book, is the West of the Roman legal tradition' (14). In the last part of this review, I will emphasise the need for this dialogue […]
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671610
21 August 2026
BOOK REVIEW: James Q. WHITMAN, De l’esprit des lois by Montesquieu, edited by Benjamin Hoffmann [Paris: Éditions Gallimard, 2024] (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 126-130)
Charles Louis de Secondat Baron de la Brède et de Montesquieu's De l 'Esprit des Lois created a sensation when it was first published in 1748, for reasons that I will touch on in this review; but contemporary readers are likely to balk at reading it from end to end. Montesquieu packed, so it seems, pretty much everything he knew into De l'Esprit des Lois. He knew a lot; and it can be a struggle to plow through it all, for example when it comes to his lengthy, and out of date, disquisitions on German law. I will not suggest that readers - even the learned readers of Comparative Legal History - should feel ashamed if they lose steam while trying.
That said, Montesquieu was, in a word, a genius. His thoughts, some of them presented in chapters hardly longer than post-it notes, are always engaging and frequently brilliant, even if now and then they seem comical or even sinister. (More on that anon.) He deserves more credit than he always gets, for example for discovering fundamental principles of proportionality and deterrence that we usually attribute to Bentham. Not least, he brought a kind of intellectual daring to his comparative work that was rare in the mid-eighteenth century, and that remains rare today - so much so that the reaction of this reviewer, after reading this excellent new annotated edition from Gallimard, is to wonder, wistfully, whether we are falling short of the standard he set two and a half centuries ago.
What modern readers undoubtedly know best are Montesquieu's reflections on the functioning of monarchy, democracy and despotism, which occupy the opening books of the Esprit des Lois and still hold a place on the political theory syllabus. There is much more to Montesquieu's masterpiece than that, though, most of which is neglected or dismissed. This is notably true of one of the claims on which he was most insistent, his theory of the formative effect of different climates on the law. 'Climate determinism', as Ralf Michaels drily writes, 'seems eccentric to comparative lawyers today'. So it does, though Michaels makes an audacious case for a creative return to it. I will not defend climate determinism in its original form (and neither does Michaels). But I will defend the scientific, and moral, attitude that led Montesquieu to it. [...]
To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671608
17 July 2026
CLH ARTICLE: Ann MUMFORD, Re-enacting the judicial philosophy of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.: Saunders v Vautier and Claflin v Claflin compared (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1, pp. 97-125) [OPEN ACCESS]
Abstract:
Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. sat on the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts in 1889, when, in the case of Claflin v Claflin, he joined the decision that a trust may not be modified if the intention of the testator would be undermined. Claflin rejected Lord Cottenham’s reasoning in Saunders v Vautier that, under certain circumstances, beneficiaries may compel the termination of the trust and transfer the property to them. Claflin v Claflin and Saunders v Vautier are perhaps the two most famous cases in Anglo-American Equity. Through a detailed examination of manuscripts, this article offers a comparative expansion of the US and English histories, and particularly considers the role played by Holmes. Re-enactment theory offers the possibility of creating, or reliving, the intellectual process that led to Claflin, thus revealing a significant moment in the history of US federalism.
To read the article, please click here. The article is available in open access; the full issue is freely accessible online to members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671607
10 July 2026
CLH ARTICLE: Lukasz Jan KORPOROWICZ, The Polish Blackstone: an examination of nineteenth-century Polish scholars’ interpretations of Blackstone and his Commentaries (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1, pp. 73-96) [OPEN ACCESS]
The principal goal of this article is to address the reception of William Blackstone's legal thought and the awareness of his contributions within the context of nineteenth-century Polish legal scholarship. Despite the considerable differences between English and Polish legal traditions, the limited proficiency in the English language within Poland, and the relatively gradual evolution of Polish legal thought, Blackstone's works were acknowledged by academic circles in Poland in the nineteenth century. Over time, this awareness manifested in direct engagement with certain aspects of Blackstone's perspectives. Nonetheless, the temporal disparity between Blackstone's period of influence and the evolution of legal scholarship in partitioned Poland significantly limited the practical opportunities for the integration and application of Blackstonian jurisprudence.
03 July 2026
CALL FOR PAPERS: Ius Commune Workshop on Comparative Legal History - Ius Commune in the Making: Failure and the Law (Leuven: KULeuven, 24 NOV 2026) [DEADLINE 15 AUG 2026]
The 30th Ius Commune Conference will take place in Leuven (24-25 November 2026), and a Workshop will be devoted to “Failure and the Law.”
The workshops on “Comparative Legal History – Ius Commune in the Making”
aim to reveal and understand the nature and effects of various legal formants
in the development of law. Indeed, forces of legal formants are too often lost
or hidden beneath a superficies of commonalities. History is a living
laboratory. In the past, we explored the role of legal actors (2014), legal
sources (2016), force of local laws (2017), methods and dynamics of law (2018),
networks (2019), paradigmatic shifts (2020), great debates in the history of
law (2021), the concept of innovation in law (2023), manifestations of nature
in law (2024), and meaning in law (2025).
This Workshop is dedicated to the place of failure in the life of the law. Not every effort triggers a successful outcome, it should be noted. Efforts in the realm of the law are no exception, and endeavours may fail because of different reasons and at different stages. Failure should be considered a learning experience both for those who attempted to succeed and for those who might attempt in the future. Efforts should not always be considered success stories, yet they should always be considered tools for change and for the advancement of legal science. Thus all legal acting has the inherent capacity to profit from learned experiences, and one should even hold such is the duty of legal scholarship. Failure as a working definition means that a wilful act has not been received effectively, yet the qualification of an act as a failure in itself is profoundly normative as this takes its place in the fabric of legal debate.
The story of failure and success is therefore multi-layered. Failed attempts are omnipresent throughout history and can take different forms. Researchers are invited to explore in this Workshop examples of failed attempts to change or preserve the law as it is, be these, amongst others, legislative, judicial, doctrinal, educational. It may be a failure concerning the fabric of the law itself, as well as in the law’s interaction with the real world. Limitations can relate to several aspects, including the practical such as availability of time, access to (re)sources, flaws in argumentative lines, skills of the human resources involved. For example, Diocletian’s Edictum de Pretiis Rerum Venalium failed in 301 to stop inflation. The medieval feudal system, that failed to maintain personal ties of fealty but turned into a system hereditary rights of succession, eventually creating its own demise. Closer in time, private law codification efforts, such as early-nineteenth century attempts in the Low Countries, provided timely awareness on the merits and weaknesses of those corpora of the law in Europe and beyond. The invention, import or abolition of concepts, rules or methodologies which are considered (not) to fit well may be an illustrative area of research.
Comparative legal historians can benefit from an inventory of what went “wrong” in the selected failure in making or changing the law. This Workshop aims to take stock, inviting for papers that could serve as “logbooks” in that learning process, helping to document failure as it emerged. Awareness of working points can assist in attaining a quick catch-up, something that is recurrent in other sciences, where researchers need to avoid replicating failed exercises that may have taken place in other laboratories. Even when not all experiences may be considered successful, comparative legal history can evolve when failed experiences are assessed and reconsidered.
Senior researchers and PhD candidates are invited to submit an abstract of a paper related to the above-mentioned theme. Abstracts (max. 400 words) should be sent to Agustín Parise (agustin.parise@maastrichtuniversity.nl) no later than 15 August 2026. Shortly after that, the authors will be informed whether their papers are selected for a presentation during the Workshop. All contributions should be in English. Co-authored papers will be also considered. The organizing committee will give preference to early-career researchers when facing submissions of similar quality.
Researchers from within and outside the Ius Commune Research School will
be eligible to present abstracts. Please
also forward this call to colleagues who might be interested.
Should you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact a member
of the organizing committee,
Harry Dondorp (j.h.dondorp@vu.nl)
Wouter Druwé (wouter.druwe@kuleuven.be)
Michael Milo (j.m.milo@uu.nl)
Pim Oosterhuis (janwillem.oosterhuis@maastrichtuniversity.nl)
Agustín Parise (agustin.parise@maastrichtuniversity.nl)
CLH ARTICLE: Henrik-Riko HELD, Ius commune, Venetian governance, and Croatian Glagolitic culture: testaments from the countryside of Šibenik in the early modern period (1637–1713) (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1, pp. 55-72)
In the article, I discuss the entanglement of ius commune and Croatian Glagolitic culture under the auspices of Venetian rule in the early modern period. I analyse 222 testaments written in the Croatian language and Glagolitic script between 1637 and 1713 by Glagolitic priests in the countryside of Šibenik, on the eastern Adriatic coast, then under Venetian rule. I address in particular the terminology employed, as well as the structure of the testaments. I compare them with models found elsewhere in Europe, as evidenced by relevant notarial formularies. Finally, I examine the issue of the validity of testaments composed by ostensibly unauthorised persons (parish priests).
12 June 2026
JOURNAL: Comparative Legal History XIV (2026), nr. 1 (Jun)
05 June 2026
CLH ARTICLE: William PARTLETT, Constitutional nationalism and remembered history: the post-Soviet example (Comparative Legal History, XIII (2025), nr. 2 (December), pp. 277-305)
Abstract:
This article will argue that national history can further the project of constitutional self-government even in formerly authoritarian countries. Examining the former Soviet republics, it will describe how remembering forgotten or suppressed democratic constitutional ideas and arguments from national history can help support the project of constitutional self-government. This form of ‘constitutional nationalism’ counters arguments that constitutional self-government is a project of convergence with western best practices. It instead links it to long-standing national struggles to adapt the balanced constitution of constitutional self-government to the national context. ‘Constitutional nationalism’ therefore relies on a different approach to history. Rather than understanding national history in countries with a long history of authoritarianism as something to ignore or overcome, it views this history as a potential source of (often suppressed) ideas and inspiration for helping the project of constitutional self-government today.
To read the article, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.
DOI: 10.1080/2049677X.2025.2579474
22 May 2026
CLH ARTICLE: Mehmed BECIC, The Commercial Law for Bosnia and Herzegovina from 1883: A legal transplant debate perspective (Comparative Legal History, XIII (2025), nr. 2 (December), pp. 222-251)
The subject of this article is the Commercial Law for Bosnia and Herzegovina from 1883. This law represented a legal transplant of German commercial law. At the time of its adoption in 1883, the Commercial Law did not represent a mirror of society. However, archival sources point to the fact that the government did not actually aim to impose a law that reflected the socio-economic conditions or business and commercial practices in Bosnia and Herzegovina. The imposition of this legal transplant was aimed at unifying commercial law in a unified customs territory. A contextual analysis, based on archival sources, economic policies and economic history, confirmed that the government was interested in imposing precisely this kind of legal solution (legal transplant) to achieve specific legal, social and economic effects and transform the existing socio-legal and economic system of Bosnia and Herzegovina.













