Search

Showing posts with label Journal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Journal. Show all posts

20 October 2026

ONLINE SEMINAR: History and Law Seminar: Meet the editors of legal history journals (30 NOV, 4pm GMT)

 Abstract:

Join Allison Tirres, Craig Green and David Schorr for a discussion about publishing research in law and history. This session offers an opportunity to hear editors’ perspectives on developing an article, choosing a journal and navigating submission, peer review and revisions. Whether you are preparing your first submission or developing your next publication, come along to ask questions and gain practical insights into the publishing process. Postgraduate researchers, early career scholars and colleagues at all career stages are welcome.

More information here. 

(source: Dr Victoria Barnes)

16 October 2026

JOURNAL: Právněhistorické studie / Legal History Studies LVI (2026), Nr. 2 [OPEN ACCESS]

 


On the journal:
Právněhistorické studie / Legal History Studies (Charles University journal; below referred to as PHS or Journal) is a scientific journal listed in the international prestigious database SCOPUS. The journal is published by Charles University in Prague under the guarantee of the Department of Legal History of the Faculty of Law of Charles University. It is published by the Karolinum Press. The journal focuses on the field of legal history and related topics. Issue 1 of the Journal was published by the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences Publishing in June 1955. The Journal was initially published by the Cabinet of Legal History of the Czechoslovak Academy of Science (CSAV), later by the Institute of State and Law (CSAV) and then by the Institute of Legal History of the Faculty of Law of Charles University. PHS is issued three times a year in April, August, and December and it presents original scientific works/papers as well as reviews, annotations and news from the scientific field of legal history. It also introduces annotated texts of a legal history nature. PHS accepts manuscripts from domestic as well as foreign authors. Manuscripts submitted by foreign authors are published in original language, namely in English, Slovak, German, French, Italian or Polish. PHS (ISSN 0079-4929) is registered in the Czech national ISSN centre (supervised by the State Technical Library). The Journal is registered by the Ministry of Culture of the Czech Republic according to Act No. 46/2000 Sb., on Rights and Liabilities for the Publishing of Periodicals and Change of Some Acts (Press Act), and it is allocated with registration number of periodical press MK E 18813. PHS is an open journal and ensures open access to scientific data (Open Access). The entire content is released as open to the public on the web pages of the journal.

Table of contents (with links to the articles):

  • Editorial
    Petra Skřejpková
    • Od rituálov k alimentácii: Náčrt raného vývoja fideikomisov v prospech familia libertorum
      Timotej Práznovský
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.550
      Abstract:
      The paper explores the early development of the Roman legal institution known as the fideicommissum familiae relictum, with a particular focus on its application in favour of groups of freedmen (familia libertorum). It argues that the phrase ne de nomine suo exiret – commonly found in testamentary dispositions and funerary inscriptions – reflects a concern with ensuring the continuity of burial rites and private cults (sacra privata). Drawing on epigraphic evidence and legal sources, particularly the Digest of Justinian and fragments from jurists such as Aburnius Valens and Scaevola, the paper examines how land bequests to freedmen were structured to guarantee the upkeep of tombs and the perpetuation of ancestral worship. The analysis reveals that over time, particularly from the mid-2nd century CE onward, the institution appears to have shifted towards a more alimentary function, providing support for freedmen in the absence of biological heirs. Legislative developments, such as Hadrian’s ban on dispositions to uncertain persons (personae incertae), curtailed the long-term application of such fideicommissa, leading to alternative legal mechanisms, including transfers to municipalities. The development of fideicommissa in favour of freedmen thus illustrates broader transformations in Roman private law and social practice, including the decline of traditional religion and the rise of new forms of property management and welfare provision in the Roman world.

    • K vplyvu provinčných práv a východorímskych právnických škôl na zavedenie pojmu dos adventicia do justiniánskej kodifikácie
      Róbert Brtko
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.551
      Abstract:
      The article examines the origin and legal significance of the concept of dos adventicia in Roman law. Although Justinianic sources and post-classical legal texts distinguish between dos profecticia and dos adventicia, the article proceeds from the thesis that this distinction was not originally formulated by classical Roman jurists. On the basis of an analysis of Ulpian’s fragment D. 23, 3, 5, the relevant scholia to the Basilica, the post-classical Regulae Ulpiani, and imperial constitutions preserved in Justinian’s Code, it is shown that classical law primarily operated with the category of dos profecticia, whereas other forms of dowry were defined only negatively, that is, as dowry not originating from the father of the family or from his property. Particular attention is paid to the interpolated passages in D. 23, 3, 5, 9 and D. 23, 3, 5, 11, as well as to the rescript of Emperor Gordian III preserved in C. I. 6, 20, 4. The article further examines the influence of provincial legal traditions, Hellenistic legal culture, and the pedagogical activity of Eastern Roman law schools, especially those in Berytus and Constantinople, on the terminology and systematics of the legal regulation of dowry. It concludes that dos adventicia should be understood not as an authentic classical concept, but rather as a product of post-classical legal development that was later incorporated into Justinian’s codification.
    • Between Custom and Sanction: Theft in the Vinodol Code and the Poljica Statute
      Fuad-Meša Čičić
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.552
      Abstract:
      This paper addresses the regulation of theft as an illicit act in two major medieval Croatian legal monuments: the Vinodol Code (1288) and the Statute of Poljica. Rather than offering a systematic comparison of legal systems, the study concentrates on the legal nature, normative structure, and penal treatment of theft within these statutory frameworks, situating the offence in its broader social and institutional context. The central premise is that, although medieval law did not articulate theft through modern criminal-law categories, both statutes treated it as conduct attracting distinctly criminal sanctions rather than as a purely civil wrong. Attention is directed to the criteria shaping liability and punishment, including the manner of commission, the value of the stolen property, the status of the parties, and the communal or territorial context of the offence. In the Vinodol Code, theft is predominantly addressed through graded pecuniary sanctions and restitution, reflecting a compensatory model. By contrast, the Statute of Poljica adopts a markedly stricter penal regime, frequently prescribing corporal punishment, capital sanctions, and social exclusion, thereby emphasizing deterrence and collective self-protection within a customary legal order. Both legal monuments place considerable emphasis on communal participation in adjudication, including compurgation and character-based proof, illustrating a legal culture in which property offences were regulated through collective responsibility and social control. While certain conceptual parallels with Roman law may be observed, the regulation of theft in both texts is primarily rooted in native legal traditions shaped by local social structures and customary norms. The paper situates theft as a key indicator of the criminal dimension of medieval Croatian statutory law and its role in preserving social order and communal cohesion.

    • Autokratické tendence německého císaře Viléma II. ve vztahu k legislativnímu procesu Říšského sněmu (1888–1900)
      František Stellner, Kristina Kaiserová
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.553
      Abstract:
      The study “Autocratic Tendencies of German Emperor Wilhelm II in Relation to the Legislative Process of the Reichstag (1888–1900)” analyzes the constitutional and political framework of the German Empire during the reign of Wilhelm II, focusing on his approach to the legislative process and interaction with the Reichstag. It examines whether the emperor’s attitude toward parliament evolved in connection with personnel changes in the highest German and Prussian offices and how the dual identity of “emperor-king” influenced governance. The paper discusses mechanisms of pressure and circumvention applied by Wilhelm II toward the Reichstag, including rhetoric, court networks, and personnel policy, and evaluates their limits within the federal structure. It also addresses the concept of “personal rule” and its historiographical interpretations, contrasting rhetorical antiparliamentarism with practical dependence on parliamentary majorities. The analysis combines micro- and macro-historical perspectives, using constitutional texts, parliamentary records, and correspondence of key actors. The conclusion emphasizes that despite autocratic impulses, the emperor’s power was structurally constrained, and legislative outcomes depended on negotiation and compromise, contributing to the gradual parliamentarization of decision-making in the German Empire.
    • Výzva svědomí a hledání spravedlnosti – Tolstého „Vzkříšení“ z pohledu práva
      Radim Seltenreich
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.554
      Abstract:
      In his article, the author discusses Tolstoy’s work Resurrection, which is often characterized as a distinctly “legal novel”. For a better understanding of the context, he first introduces us to Tolstoy’s life and work, in which law played an important role, if only because he studied law, even though he did not complete his studies. In this context, for example, he showed a lifelong interest in the issue of the death penalty. The novel Resurrection is based on a real case that Tolstoy learned about from the famous Russian lawyer Koni. Tolstoy changed the facts somewhat, but it is interesting to note that in the novel he makes precise references to specific legal provisions during the court proceedings. The work is a strong criticism of criminal law and the prison system in Russia at the time, with Tolstoy also addressing the philosophy of crime and punishment, rejecting the punishment of one person by another as part of his “Christian anarchism”.

    • Veřejní notáři na meziválečné Podkarpatské Rusi
      David Hubený
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.555
      Abstract:
      As in many other areas of the administration of Subcarpathian Ruthenia, in the area of justice, a number of temporary measures persisted, which proved to be long-term, but mainly functional, even if they did not fully satisfy the call for the fulfillment of autonomous status. In the case of public notaries, this was also mostly due to the fact that an independent organizational arrangement would not be practical and viable, considering the size and population of the given territory. Therefore, the public notaries of Subcarpathia were initially administered by the Košice judicial board, or rather by the local high court, and later joined the organization of Slovak public notaries. Looking at the biographies of many public notaries, one cannot help but get the impression that in the case of appointment to the position, it was a reward for previous political or official activity in favor of Czechoslovakia or the promotion of Slavic reciprocity, sometimes, on the contrary, it could be a saturation of a not entirely reliable public figure. Although, considering the very small number of notaries, it might seem that in the conditions of Subcarpathian Ruthenia it was a lucrative position ensuring more than a decent income, most of the public notaries there got into financial problems in the first half of the thirties, and even in times of boom not all positions were economically advantageous enough to ensure their holders a sufficient livelihood. Knowing this fact, it is clear how very poor Subcarpathian Ruthenia was and how desperate the situation of the vast majority of the local population was.

    • Německé vojenské soudnictví a vojenské trestní právo se zvláštním zřetelem k Protektorátu Čechy a Morava
      Jaromír Tauchen
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.556
      Abstract:
      The article deals with the activities of the German military judiciary (Wehrmachtjustiz) in the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia during the period of Nazi occupation. Despite its significance, this issue has so far been neglected in Czech legal historiography. The study presents a systematic analysis of the structure, legal basis and operation of German military courts, whose jurisdiction extended beyond German military personnel to include Czech civilians. Particular attention is paid to the legal foundations of military criminal law, the specific features of court proceedings, and the ideological instrumentalization of military justice as a tool of repression. The functioning of military courts is illustrated through selected institutional examples, especially the military court of the 193rd Division stationed in Prague. The study demonstrates how military criminal law and procedure, especially after 1939, gradually developed into an instrument of terror used to suppress resistance, discipline soldiers and enforce ideological conformity. The text is based on original archival materials, including directives, military court rulings and legal regulations of the Third Reich.
    • Kodifizierung vertraglicher Rechtsgeschäfte zwischen natürlichen Personen im V. Teil des Bürgerlichen Gesetzbuches von 1964 in der Tschechoslowakei. Allgemeine Definition, politischer und internationaler Kontext und konzeptionelle Fragen
      Jiří Šouša, Vít Mužík
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.557
      Abstract:
      Following the recent anniversary of the Czechoslovak Civil Code of 1964, this article contributes to the legal-historical and civil law scientific discourse on this legal regulation. The article is the first of two articles focusing on contractual obligations between natural persons. These obligations were intended to be supplementary to the services provided mainly by legal entities. It focuses primarily on codification work concerning contractual obligation law, its conceptualization, and the legal institution of civil assistance, all in the context of the preparation of the 1964 Civil Code, or rather in the context of the recodification of law in Czechoslovakia and other Eastern Bloc countries in the 1960s. The article also reflects specific cases and points out the similarities and specific features that distinguished the Civil Code of 1964 from a historical and international perspective. The article shows the extent to which the examined regulation of Part V of the Civil Code of 1964 was an expression of the political doctrine of the 1960s in the context of other innovations, or in relation to the traditional Marxist-Leninist doctrine. The article shows whether, and to what extent, similar to the later International Trade Code, it followed (or rather suffered from) traditional elements of obligations, albeit in a modified and truncated form and using the terminology of the time, in contrast to the rest of the 1964 Civil Code. The article highlights the differences between law in books and law in action. It therefore also addresses issues of continuity and discontinuity, autonomy of the parties’ free will, and the scope for judicial discretion with regard to the topic under examination. The article also reflects the finding that experience with the Civil Code of 1964 shows that the political utilitarianism of law does not necessarily limit its adaptability and functionality. On the contrary, even such regulations can be very adaptable to social and legal evolution. The most important general findings and insights from the research are clearly summarized in the conclusion. The article will be followed by another article by the same authors, which will focus on specific legal institutions of contractual law between natural persons according to the original wording of Part V of the Czechoslovak Civil Code of 1964.

    • „V krvi důkaz, ztratíš průkaz!“ aneb k trestnému činu opilství v socialistickém Československu
      Milan Dobeš
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.558
      Abstract:
      The article focuses on the offence of drunkenness, understood as an endangerment offence, with particular emphasis on drink-driving. It combines a doctrinal legal analysis with an examination of criminal files from the District Court for Prague 1 and surveys the interpretation of the statutory elements, investigative and evidentiary practice, and sanctioning policy. In the sanctioning dimension, a central role is played by disqualification from activity – most notably disqualification from driving – conceived as an instrument of both special and general prevention and as a means of the immediate protection of public safety. The imposition and duration of disqualification reflected the degree of intoxication, the nature and circumstances of the driving, recidivism, and the offender’s professional responsibility; in more serious cases it was supplemented by a custodial sentence. The article also addresses practical issues in the enforcement of disqualification and their implications. The individualisation of punishment was further shaped by assessments and guarantees issued by workplace collectives and other socialist organisations, which could support the choice of a more lenient sanction or the early remission of the remainder of the disqualification.

    • The Concept of Possession in Roman Law and Common Law
      Barbora Hniličková
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.559
      Abstract:
      This article examines the legal regulation of possession in Roman law and in contemporary common law. Its objective is to identify and assess the key similarities and differences between these two legal traditions and to demonstrate that, despite their fundamental systematic distinctions, the influence of Roman law on the development of common law has been more substantial than often assumed. The analysis shows that, notwithstanding divergent historical developments and systematic characteristics, both systems articulate conceptually comparable understandings of possession. The findings further confirm that Roman law contributed, at least to some degree, to the shaping of common law, underscoring the enduring reach of Roman law not only within continental legal systems but also within modern common law jurisdictions.
    • Crimen maiestatis: Symbolism and Ritual Protection of Authority in Roman Criminal Law
      Marie Neumann
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.560
      Abstract:
      This article focuses on the development of the crime of high treason throughout the era of the Roman Empire, focusing on symbolism and ritual protection of authority in Roman criminal law. Using legal sources and historical cases, it illustrates the changes of this offence, with an emphasis on the changing perceptions of authority. The article draws on legal sources, especially the Code of Justinian and Theodosius and the Digest of Justinian, but also on non-legal sources, especially the work of Titus Livy, as well as other ancient historians. Furthermore, the article works with a variety of domestic and foreign secondary sources, especially monographs and scholarly articles.
    • Herbert David: Justice v říšské župě Sudety optikou vzpomínek jejího hlavního představitele
      Adam Šplíchal
      DOI  10.14712/2464689X.2026.561
      Abstract:
      This study examines the fate of justice in the Reichsgau Sudetenland through the recollections of its leading representative, Dr. Herbert David (1900–1987). Drawing on archival research in German repositories and David’s own memoirs, the article reconstructs the transformation of the legal system in the Sudetenland after its annexation to the Third Reich in 1938. David’s memories, written decades later, represent a unique and hitherto underexplored source that illuminates the personnel challenges, institutional restructuring, and ideological pressures faced by the judiciary in this border region. His testimony reveals both the practical functioning of courts under Nazi rule and the tensions between local actors and central Reich authorities. By contextualizing David’s narrative with secondary literature on Nazi law and Sudeten German politics, the article highlights the interplay between law, ideology, and power in a newly established Reichsgau. It also addresses the limitations and biases of David’s recollections, while emphasizing their value as the only surviving insider account of judicial administration in the Sudetenland during the years 1938–1945.

    • Právní aspekty reorganizace československého divadelnictví po druhé světové válce
      Kateřina Šustová
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.562
      Abstract: 
      After World War II (in May 1945), Czechoslovakian theaters were reopened. The so-called theater revolution began, during which the theater industry in Czechoslovakia experienced fundamental changes in organizational structure. Despite the efforts of Austria-Hungary and the First Czechoslovak Republic, this space was still regulated by the Theater Act of November 25, 1850 (Ministry of the Interior law No. 454/1850). There were also plans to consolidate the regulation of the theater industry in Czechoslovakia, as Hungarian legal article XXXI had been in effect since 1848 in Slovakia. This was a different (and even older) legal regulation than the one in Bohemia. This work explores the legal considerations of the aforementioned reorganization of theaters. The main goal of the research is to describe how the pre-World War regulatory environment affected the evolution of theater industry regulation thereafter, including mapping out any significant path dependencies. This work subsequently addresses the regulatory changes that occurred in the theater industry after the adoption of the Theater Act in 1948. This author found that the adoption of the Theater Act in 1948 capped a long-term effort by theaters to modify the legal regulation of the theater industry. However, this impeded entrepreneurship and gave monopoly to government-designated theater operators, who were allowed to use the property of the previously private theaters. On the other hand, there were some positive changes, particularly in the field of theater education and puppet theater, which came to be seen as on equal footing with other types of theater arts. However, even the Theater Act of 1948 was not sufficient, and new theater regulation, Act No. 55/1957, on theater activities (Theatre Act), emerged shortly thereafter and came into effect on November 16, 1957.

    • That’s What Should Be Done! Reflections on the Margins of the Monograph of Peter Candy, Ancient Maritime Loan Contracts
      Maciej Jońca
      DOI 10.14712/2464689X.2026.563
      Abstract:
      In 2025, Dr. Peter Candy (University of Cambridge) published a monograph titled “Ancient Maritime Loan Contracts”. In it, he challenged many of the findings that had been firmly established in the study of Roman law since the 19th century. In his examination of Roman maritime law, he first undertook a “democratization” of the ancient sources. This led him to a surprising conclusion. Namely, the Romans (like the Greeks) did not recognize a separate maritime loan contract. They used a single, consistent loan structure that could be adapted for various purposes – including conducting business at sea. This work deserves attention among legal historians because the author not only debunked a (seemingly) unshakable dogma but also demonstrated how ancient sources remain a flexible and forward-looking subject for research. There are no topics about which nothing more can be written, as long as there are people who are not afraid to ask old sources new questions.

    • Ve službě právní historii – za profesorem JUDr. Karlem Malým, DrSc., dr.h.c.mult.
      Vladimír Kindl
    • Zemřel doc. JUDr. Karel Schelle, CSc., spiritus rector Encyklopedie českých právních dějin
      Ladislav Vojáček
    • BALOGH, E. (ed.). Golden Bulls and Chartas: European Medieval Documents of Liberties
      Jan Marčík
    • VYŠNÝ, P. – MARTIŠKOVÁ, M. Praktikum zo svetových dejín štátu a práva
      Ingrid Lanczová
    • POLLÁK, A. – KOLUMBER, D. – GAJARSKÝ, A. Keď zákony tvorí vláda a parlament mlčí. Zmocňovacia normotvorba na česko-slovenskom príklade v rokoch 1918–1945
      Jan Kabát
    • TAUCHEN, J. (ed.) – KUBEŠ, V. Dějiny filozofie práva
      Vojtěch Jarkovský
    • LACLAVÍKOVÁ, M. – DOMANICKÝ, M. Počiatky zľudovenia súdnictva a etablovanie funkcie sudcov z ľudu na Slovensku v rokoch 1948 – 1953 (normatívna báza a prvotné problémy)
      Ingrid Lanczová

    Read the full issue here.

    18 September 2026

    JOURNAL: Rechtsgeschichte – Legal History, Journal of the Max Planck Institute for Legal History and Legal Theory, Rg 34 (2026)

    (image source: Rg)

    Rechtsgeschichte – Legal History 34 (2026) out now

    Journal of the Max Planck Institute for Legal History and Legal Theory

    Last year saw the publication of two significant new books on Rudolf von Jhering, one of the most original legal scholars of the 19th century. In the Research section of this year’s issue of our Institute journal, the books’ authors present their findings for discussion. While Michael Kunze traces Jhering’s life-long quest for a secular foundation of law as an invisible normative order, Mathias Reimann finds both brilliant insights and chaotic tendencies in Jhering’s writings.

    Dave De ruysscher’s article on the history of bills of exchange in Western Europe argues that their regulatory framework remained relatively indeterminate between c. 1450 and 1680. Only gradually did a synthesis of Genoese and Dutch methodologies establish itself as the dominant approach. Beate Althammer explores the history of pardoning practices as a part of 19th-century criminal justice reforms. Her analysis of petitions for royal mercy in England and Prussia leads her to question the narrative of a linear change of legal order and pardoning practices. Triin Tark offers a Baltic perspective on the translation of legal texts during the interwar period. She demonstrates how the consistent terminology for ethnic minorities used in the Estonian Law on Cultural Autonomy (1925) was replaced with an eclectic mix of vocabulary by the League of Nations’ translators.

    The Research section is completed by Erk Volkmar Heyen taking a closer look at the iconography of the courtroom table from the joint perspective of art and legal history. His analysis of 19th-century French and Belgian satirical images of the judiciary focuses on the relationship between religion and the state. 

    Art and creativity are also the subjects of this year‘s Forum section. Its 15 short contributions explore the possibilities opened up by creative methods in legal history from a global perspective – with examples from the Americas, Africa and India.

    This issue‘s Critique section offers 33 reviews of recent publications relevant to the study of legal history from late antiquity to the 21st century. Under Comptes rendus, we briefly present some key publications by researchers at our Institute.

    Thorsten Keiser‘s Marginalia contribution deals with a key characteristic of the Venetian Republic’s constitution from the late Middle Ages to the 18th century: the anonymous denunciation (denuncia segreta). The print issue‘s series of images is also devoted to Venice; the various selected views of the lagoon city all stem from the extensive collections of Frankfurt’s Städel Museum.

    Rechtsgeschichte — Legal History 34 is now available in print from the publishers Vittorio Klostermann and online in Open Access via the journal's website.

    17 September 2026

    JOURNAL: Genere, giustizia, guerra – Ebrei in politica nel Rinascimento – Varia (Mélanges de l'École française de Rome 137-1 (2025)) [OPEN ACCESS]

    (image source: Openedition)

    Genere, giustizia, guerra (eds. Fabrice Virgili, Paolo Fonzo, Fabien Lostec, Cecilia Nubola & Toni Rovatti)

    Introduction (Fabrice Virgili, Paolo Fonzi, Fabien Lostec, Cecilia Nubola et Toni Rovatti)

    Ree, vittime: donne greche nei documenti dei tribunali militari italiani nella Grecia occupata (1941-1943) (Paolo Fonzi)
    DOI 10.4000/15hok
    Abstract:

    During the Second World War the Italian army established military tribunals in occupied Greece. As these tribunals prosecuted not only Italian soldiers but also Greek civilians for offences against the Italian military authorities, women often figure in their records. This article examines some of the instances in which women were involved in the trials as perpetrators or victims. Based on these sources the article aims to answer two main questions. The first is to what extent occupation unleashed major shifts in gender relations, challenging given patriarchal structures and thus providing the ground for new forms of female social behaviour. The second is how the Italian military authorities dealt with these new forms of social behaviour. A purely manly organism, the Italian military tribunals premised their judgments upon a conception of «paternalist protection» towards women, a protection exercised only towards certain subjects. Those women who challenged the social taxonomies of the judges were systematically denied such a protection. Therefore the records reveal the «common sense», to use Ann Stoler’s category, of the occupation authorities.

    Recels de couverture et paroles de ménagère devant le tribunal militaire (Sardaigne 1943-1944) (Fabrici Virgili)
    DOI 10.4000/15hol
    Abstract:

    An analysis of the testimony given by 28 women questioned before the Military Tribunal of the 7th Army Corps sitting in Sassari (Sardinia) during the period 1943-1944 sheds light on women’s voices in the face of military justice. These case files, which concern several cases of theft and receiving stolen goods, provide insight into the ambivalent relationships that developed between young men, soldiers and non-islanders on the one hand, and Sardinian women, housewives and women of their mothers’ age on the other, with both parties confronted by an institution that had no intention of allowing its blankets and other textile goods to be stolen. This article explores the gendered boundary between civilian and military life, combining material culture and military justice based on previously unpublished archives. It highlights the often lesser-known and more ambivalent margins of the conflict, whether geopolitical (Sardinia), social (a few housewives) or military (a few textile goods).

    Les collaboratrices face à une justice militaire d’exception Le cas des cours martiales de la République en France à la Libération (Fabien Lostec)
    DOI 10.4000/15hom
    Abstract:

    This article brings together two realities of the purge in France that are still little known: on the one hand, women tried for acts of collaboration and, on the other, the courts martial of the Republic. In a number of French regions, the Republic’s courts martial were the first legal purge tribunals. They handed down their judgements in September 1944, in a climate of great tension marked by the explosion of sentiment characteristic of the Liberation. Studying these tribunals not only sheds light on the judicial archipelago of purges, it also provides an opportunity to offer a social and gendered history of collaboration and purges. To be precise, two questions will be examined in turn, based on a previously unpublished corpus of around 1,000 judgements and around a hundred procedural files from the 38 courts martial of the Republic that France had at the time. The first question is that of the place of women in the courts, which requires us to reflect not only on the severity of their judgements but also on the notion of “épuration sauvage”, used by some to describe the activity of these courts martial. The second question is that of the acts of which the women were accused, which, although they were at the crossroads of legality and morality, could not be summed up simply as sentimental collaboration. In the face of these accusations, the accused are also given the floor to examine their arguments in their defence, which are largely based on gender stereotypes.

    Parlare tacere tradire Collaborazioniste e partigiane nei processi del secondo dopoguerra (Cecilia Nubola) 
    DOI 10.4000/15hon
    Abstract:

    Starting with the sentences of the Special Tribunals established after WWII in Italy and the examination of a certain number of significant case studies, this paper/essay investigates some aspects of the activities and choices made by women and girls during the civil war (1943-1945). The investigation focusses on the lives of women who–in order to survive the war–had betrayed and denounced people on either side, siding–as they found it necessary–with the RSI or the Resistance. The testimonies given during the trials make it possible to shed new light on the female contribution to the «Civil Resistance» and to recognize its role and importance. The aim is to overcome the dichotomy between women as either «victims» or «heroines» and to highlight their awareness and acceptance of the risks, the choices, as well as the ideal and political motivations that supported their partisan struggles, which were often not recognized in the post-war period.

    Segnare la colpa Donne e dovere di testimonianza sulle violenze di guerra nei processi del lungo dopoguerra italiano (1944-2013) (Toni Rovatti)
    DOI 10.4000/15hoo
    Abstract:

    This essay explores the role of women in Italian trials for war crimes and collaboration spanning the “long period” from 1944 to 2013, focusing on their participation as victims, accusers, and observers. Drawing on judicial records and trial reporting, the study underscores the vital contribution of women to the reconstruction of historical truth within transitional justice frameworks—contexts often marked by forms of summary justice. Between 1944 and 1950, women played a central role in grassroots denunciations and demands for accountability. In the later trials from the 1990s onward, female testimonies became increasingly centered on memory and moral reparation, frequently voiced by the daughters and granddaughters of victims. The essay concludes by addressing persistent gender asymmetries within the judiciary and the ongoing tension between recognition and the stereotyping of women’s voices in judicial settings.

    Read these articles and the rest of the journal in open access on openedition. 


     

    28 August 2026

    JOURNAL: Pro Memorie. Bijdragen tot de Rechtsgeschiedenis der Nederlanden XXVIII (2026), nr. 1

    (image source: AUP)

    Redactioneel (Bram Van Hofstraeten & Paul Brood)
    DOI 10.5117/PM2026.1.001.REDA

    De zaak Hendrick Schilt. De methodes van uitsluiting van de WIC in Nederlands-Brazilië met betrekking tot haar eigen ambtenaren, 1630-1654 (Florian Herrendorf)
    DOI 10.5117/PM2026.1.002.HERR
    Abstract:
    As trust is essential for maintaining successful commercial relations, groups of traders relied on methods of exclusion to ensure that everyone carried out their agreed tasks. The Dutch West India Company (WIC), being a heterogeneous commercial organisation, therefore, could not function properly without employing formal methods of exclusion, both internally and in the territories it governed, of which taking recourse to courts was the most important. However, historians have failed to include the WIC in current debates on the principal-agent problem in early modern trade. As such, we know very little about the actual functioning of the judicial system in its overseas territories in general, and in its most important colony, Dutch Brazil, in particular. This article tries to address this problem by using a case study focused on a lawsuit against several Company officials to investigate the workings of the legal system of Dutch Brazil.

    De civiele rechtspraak van de schepenbank van Thorn. De zaak Christina Halermans versus Dirk Brouns (1685-1688) (Bram Van Hofstraeten)
    DOI 10.5117/PM2026.1.003.HOFS
    Abstract:

    This study examines the civil jurisdiction of the bench of aldermen of Thorn in the early modern period, focusing on its procedural practices, social accessibility, and the influence of learned legal traditions. Contrary to the notion of a general ‘Great Litigation Decline’ in eighteenth-century Europe, Thorn experienced a relatively low but steady rate of civil litigation, with a notable peak in the late seventeenth century. During the eighteenth century the court increasingly relied upon external impartial legal scholars in order to formulate a verdict which may have contributed to a reduced confidence in the local justice system. A detailed case study of Christina Halermans vs. Dirk Brouns (1685–1688) illustrates the court’s procedural complexity, the tactical – and not always equally careful – use of legal citations, and the increasing influence of legal arguments rooted in Roman law and the ius commune. This shift reflects a growing disjunction between local customary law and the academic legal discourse dominating civil litigation, which may have discouraged litigants from turning to the local court. The study suggests that the court’s procedural stagnation during the eighteenth century was less due to internal disorganization and more to the inability of local magistrates to navigate increasingly sophisticated legal reasoning. In addition, the study demonstrates that lawyers (instead of judges) played a crucial role in the reception of Roman law in early modern Europe.

    Les immunités des ecclésiastiques ont leurs bornes Een moordende theologant en de vorstelijke rechtsbedeling in de Oostenrijkse Nederlanden (1749-1750) (Dirk Leyder)
    DOI 10.5117/PM2026.1.004.LEYD
    Abstract:

    In december 1749, Martin van Meir, a 23-year-old theologian, commits two gruesome murders in the archiepiscopal seminary of Mechelen. The president of that institution decides to immediately cover up the case. The Privy Council, however, quickly uncovers the murders and obliges the Fiscal Office of the Great Council of the Netherlands in Mechelen to pursue both the murderer and his superior. The legal experts of the central government consider that the clerical immunities used as a defense by some, do not apply to either culprit. Written interventions by the archbishop of Mechelen, Thomas Philippe d’Alsace, in aid of his president (and to a lesser extent, of his homicidal student), put the regalists in Brussels on their heels, but do seem to affect the governor and the empress. Maria-Theresia eventually lets the case rest. But henceforth discussions about the immunity of clergymen will rather be settled in favor of the State.


    Hunebedden en het Romeinse recht Over de privaatrechtelijke status van hunebedden en het Romeinse recht in Drenthe (Jelle Jansen)
    DOI 10.5117/PM2026.1.005.JANS
    Abstract:

    The article begins with a sometimes fiery debate on the status of dolmens (Dutch: hunebedden), found mainly in the Dutch province of Drenthe. Lucas Oldenhuis Gratama, a.o. a lawyer, a legal historian and a member of House of parliament, stated that these dolmens were state property. With the introduction of civil codes in the Netherlands goods without an owner became stat-property and dolmens did not have an owner in the pre-codified era since they were nullius according to Roman law and not privately owned under Germanic law. Oldenhuis’ thesis was met with heavy criticism, it was generally assumed that the dolmens were part of private ownership of the land. The debate is nonetheless interesting since it raises questions on the role of Roman law in Drenthe. Scholars inspired by the anti Roman-law Groningen professor of Natural Law Van der Marck around 1800 again and again stated that Roman law played no role in rural Drenthe. This idea was already met with heavy criticism in Van der Marcks days. An examination of Drenthe’s laws as written down during the 17th and 18th century shows that Roman law played a substantial role in Drenthe’s private law, as it did in the surrounding provinces.

    Action de la loi. Juridische draagpenningen in de kledijvoorschriften van de Franse Revolutie (Alexis Vejdani)
    DOI 10.5117/PM2026.1.006.VEJD
    Abstract:

    A lasting legacy of the French Revolution and its legal reforms in France (and by extension in the various territories it occupied during this period) is the clothing prescribed for the magistrates and lawyers to be worn in court. Under the old regime the sovereign was the source of the law, therefore his magistrates wore regal robes when in session. The revolutionaries, having firmly denied this principle, designated the general will of the people as the sole source of law and therefore found inspiration with the representatives of third estate to clothe the members of the new judiciary. Along with their sombre black robes came revolutionary insignia like the cockades, ribbons in the three colours of the nation and above all medals in various forms, bearing legends such as La Loi and Action de la loi to signify the triumph of law over the tyranny of men.

    Buiten de koninklijke hand? De taaldimensie van de Belgisch-Nederlandse codificatie-opdracht (1816-1830) (Robin Navez)
    DOI 10.5117/PM2026.1.007.NAVE
    Abstract:

    The Belgian-Dutch civil code was the principle legislative project that occupied parliamentarians during the common years of Belgium and Netherlands. Since the union of these territories in 1815, the codification project had to deal with the coexistence of two main languages and the consequences of this new bilingual dimension for the drafting of the civil code to come. After a first unsuccessful attempt, a code was finally prepared by the Parliament between 1821 and 1826 under a commission led by the Belgian judge Nicolaï. A bilingual civil code was eventually promulgated in July 1830, but due to the Belgian secession, the code was considered too ‘Belgian’ and criticized for its similarity to the French one. Focussing on the issue of the drafting in two main languages, this contribution investigates the methodology used by the commission and its consequences on the project, including regarding the political issues.

    Book reviews

    •  Surinaamse rechtspraak in vogelvlucht, 1651-2024 R. Abhelakh, onder eindredactie van A. Kuipers, 155 Jaar. Gedenkboek Hof van Justitie Suriname. Hof van Justitie, Paramaribo, 2024. 279 pagina’s. ISBN 978-99914-7-568-4. In Nederland verkrijgbaar in de webwinkel van Sampreshan, €49. (Peter van den Berg)
    Read the full issue here.


     


     



     

    03 July 2026

    JOURNAL: Tijdschrift voor Rechtsgeschiedenis / Revue d'histoire du droit / The Legal History Review XCIV (2026), nr. 1-2

    Cover Tijdschrift voor Rechtsgeschiedenis / Revue d'histoire du droit / The Legal History Review

     

     Artikelen / Articles / Articles 

    Consensus and contract: Land lease in Ptolemaic Egypt (Éva Jakab)

    DOI 10.1163/15718190-20260106
    Abstract:

    In the present paper the question is raised whether ancient Greek law did know the concept of a ‘consensual contract’. Indeed, it was controversial for a long time, and opinions remained divided on it. Actually, legal historians have to struggle with the problem of the sources: the legal institutions, as understood by the actors, have to be reconstructed upon documentary sources, mirroring everyday practice. For decades, the contract theory of H.J. Wolff, the ‘Zweckverfügung’, dominated legal historian papers. Wolff attempted to develop a new terminology and structure, independent of Roman law. However, in recent publications, ‘neo-Pandektistik’ ideas can be observed. My essay focuses on lease agreements because Wolff studied this type of contract to develop his new ideas. The question of whether Wolff’s thesis holds up in every respect is also being considered.

    A discussion of the concept of lex from the Twelve Tables to the Regnum (Carlos Amunátegui Perelló)

    DOI: 10.1163/15718190-20260107
    Abstract:  

    The notion that public legislation existed during the obscure period preceding the Twelve Tables is a subject of intense debate in Roman legal and historical scholarship. This paper seeks to explore the existence of public statutes during the fifth and sixth centuries bce. It does not aim to examine the individual, often enigmatic, figures of Rome’s early kings or the specific laws attributed to them, but rather the general concept and plausibility of written legislation predating the Twelve Tables. 

    D. 9,2,51 and the role of dialectic in Julian’s interpretation of chapter one lex Aquilia (Peter Candy)

    DOI: 10.1163/15718190-20260108
    Abstract:

    D. 9,2,51 Iul. 86 dig. is one of the best known texts in Justinian’s Digest, appearing near to the end of title 9,2 on the lex Aquilia concerning damage to property. In it, the jurist Julian poses a hypothetical case in which two assailants each mortally wound a slave in separate incidents, culminating in the slave’s death. The question arises concerning the attackers’ liability under chapter one of the lex Aquilia for wrongful killing (‘occidere’). Julian’s ruling is that both should be liable to the direct statutory action. At the end of the text, he goes on to state that many solutions have been accepted by the civil law, contrary to dialectical argumentation (‘contra rationem disputandi’) for the common good (‘pro utilitate communi’). This contribution situates Julian’s approach to this problem in the context of Hellenistic philosophy, especially the branch of philosophy called dialectic that covered the field of formal logic and contained within it specific problems concerning the truth value of statements. My general thesis is that the positions taken by Julian in D. 9,2,51 and related texts are internally consistent if understood through the lens of dialectic, particularly the ancient theories concerning the truth value of statements.

    Superficies solo cedit in the Roman province of Egypt (João Costa-Neto, Henrique Porto de Castro, João G. Sarmento) 

    DOI: 10.1163/15718190-20260109
    Abstract:

    This research critically examines the assumed universality of the Roman legal rule superficies solo cedit by examining its application – or lack thereof – in Roman Egypt. Drawing on papyrological evidence, we argue that local traditions permitted the separate ownership of land and buildings, encompassing divided ownership within a single structure. These practices persisted after the Roman annexation and were recognised by Roman authorities. Thus, this study considers Egypt as a case of legal pluralism within the Empire, illustrating how Roman legal traditions coexisted with local norms rather than fully replacing them.

    Did Arcadius legislate on episcopalis audientia? And was that legislation included in the Theodosian Code? (Gideon de Jong)

    DOI: 10.1163/15718190-20260109
    Abstract:

    It is generally assumed the text of CJ 1,4,7, a law on episcopal adjudication, was issued by Arcadius as part of a larger legislative action on the 27th of July AD 398 at Mnizus. Paul Krüger’s critical edition of Justinian’s Code is primarily responsible for this assumption gaining traction. Through an exploration of the (lacking) manuscript evidence and earlier humanist editions of the Code, notably that of Gregorius Haloander, this article stresses both the place Mnizus and promulgation by Arcadius are in fact assumptions. Similarly, Krüger’s claim that CJ 1,4,7 was also part of the Theodosian Code lacks direct evidence. With an investigation of the sources the article seeks to highlight the as of yet unresolved textual problems and strengthen the basis for further legal analysis.

    The fideicommissum ‘si sine liberis decesserit’: Interpretating childlessness in the learned legal practice of the early modern Southern Netherlands (1550–1650) (Vincent Van den Eynde)

    DOI 10.1163/15718190-20260111
    Abstract:

    This article examines the interpretation of the testamentary clause si sine liberis decesserit (‘if he dies without children’) within the learned legal practice of the Southern Netherlands. Frequently attached to fideicommissary substitutions, this clause aimed to preserve family property but generated complex disputes about the meaning of ‘childlessness’. Drawing on printed consilia and decisiones, the study explores how jurists addressed issues such as posthumous children, legitimation, adoption, and monastic entry, while navigating between the clause’s literal wording and the presumed will of the testator. Analysis shows that early modern jurists interpreted liberi in a strict, biological and legitimate sense: only children born within a lawful marriage were recognized for the purpose of the clause. Illegitimate, legitimized, adopted, or fictive ‘children’ such as monasteries typically did not qualify. Because such children fell outside the scope of the clause, jurists frequently concluded that no ‘true’ children existed, and the fideicommissary condition was therefore fulfilled. Thus, in these cases the expressly designated substitute often prevailed, not because substitutes were favored as such, but because a strict, text-bound reading of liberi was deemed the safer and more faithful way to honor the testator’s will, rather than speculating about broader notions of ‘children’. As a result, the findings highlight the interplay between ius commune doctrine, local practice, and socio-economic strategies, illustrating how jurists navigated tensions between testamentary autonomy, familial patrimonial continuity, and canonical values.

    The mutual duties of parents and their children: Evidence from post-Tridentine Liège (Marie-Sophie Silan)

    DOI: 10.1163/15718190-20260112
    Abstract:

    During the Early Modern period, the family was regarded as a ‘domestic economy’, with the husband and father at its head. Although familial relationships were primarily vertical – the family was a hierarchy – they were also governed by reciprocal obligations. This was notably the case in the relationship between parents and children. Drawing on the Fourth Commandment (Ex. 20:12), children were expected to show respect, love, obedience, and to assist their parents in times of need. In turn, parents were responsible for their children’s material support and, crucially, their spiritual education. In many respects, the mutual duties binding parents and children in this period prefigure modern legal notions of maintenance obligations, which today fall squarely within the domain of law. In the context of the Reformation and Counter-Reformation, increasing emphasis was placed on the parents’ duty to give their children a strictly Catholic upbringing, as children had to be protected from any ‘heretical’ influence from an early age. Consequently, a substantial body of prescriptive literature, including manuals for confessors and treatises on domestic economy aimed at an educated lay readership, emerged to give parents advice on how to best conform to Christian ideals. Focusing on post-Tridentine Liège (c. 1563–1700) as a case study, this paper examines how these biblically grounded, reciprocal duties were disseminated among the population and articulated in local legal literature. It then compares these normative sources with evidence drawn from wills and marriage contracts preserved in notarial records. These documents offer concrete insights into how parents sought to reinforce filial duties and moral expectations through private legal instruments, thereby shedding light on the interaction between law, religion and morality within the Early Modern family.

    In the shadow of Paris: Origins and consequences of Belgian contrefaçon industry of French literary works (Katarzyna Latek)

    DOI: 10.1163/15718190-20260113
    Abstract:

    In the shadow of Paris, Belgian publishers built a remarkable industry: the mass reprinting of French literary and legal works. This article examines the phenomenon of Belgian contrefaçon – the systematic reprinting of French works between 1815 and 1854. In the absence of international copyright conventions, Belgian publishers lawfully reproduced French texts, selling them at a fraction of Parisian prices across Europe and the Americas. The article distinguishes reprinting (réimpression) from counterfeiting in the criminal sense, demonstrating that Belgian practice operated within the legal framework of the era. Drawing on the works of Dopp, Hen, Hellemans, and Verbeke, the study analyses the industry’s institutional structure, its patronage by Belgium’s political and judicial elite, and its suppression through the bilateral convention of 22 August 1852. The article identifies a significant gap in existing scholarship: the extent to which Belgian editorial modifications to reprinted French legal treatises may have influenced the transnational reception of French legal thought.

    From ‘form’ to ‘will’: The political origins of Jhering’s ‘Damaskuserlebnis’ (Wei Xiao)
    DOI: 10.1163/15718190-202601144

    Abstract:

    Jhering’s intellectual transformation from formalism to realism – manifested as a methodological transition from his early adherence to ‘conceptual jurisprudence’ to his later advocacy of ‘teleological jurisprudence’ – constitutes a profound response to the political and social upheavals of nineteenth-century Germany. In his early thought, Jhering maintained that legal formalism could effectively resist political arbitrariness and safeguard individual liberty, thereby providing the foundation for a lawful liberal state. He sought to replace the absence of constitutional governance with a systematic and autonomous science of private law that would secure a ‘system of freedom’. However, amid the unification wars and Bismarck’s Realpolitik, Jhering came to recognize that rigid legal forms often proved inadequate to address the complexities of social and political reality. Consequently, he began to emphasize the role of ‘powerful personalities’ and political decision-making, contending that in states of emergency, necessary acts of will could compensate for the limitations of legal form. Nevertheless, Jhering did not abandon his earlier ideals; he remained acutely wary of unchecked political power and insisted that such decisions must be justified and strictly constrained. Throughout his oeuvre, Jhering sought to reconcile form and will by advocating the institutionalization of political decision-making within a normative legal order. He underscored that freedom must be realized through the law and called upon political actors to embody classical virtues to ensure the legitimacy and moral integrity of their decisions.

     Book reviews

    • P. Scheibelreiter, Der ‘ungetreue’ Verwahrer, Eine Studie zur Haftungsbegründung im griechischen und frühen römischen Depositenrecht. [Münchener Beiträge zur Papyrusforschung und Antiken Rechtsgeschichte, 119]. C.H. Beck, München 2020. 318 S. (Gerhard Thür)
    • R. Jacob, Les formes premières du droit en Occident, ii : Le sacré et le juridique. puf, [Paris 2024]. 480 p. (Yann Berthelet)
    • M. Schermaier (ed.), The position of Roman slaves: Social realities and legal differences. [Dependency and slavery studies, 6]. De Gruyter, [Berlin – Boston 2023]. vii + 310 p. (Christoph Haar)
    • D. De Concilio, The Perpendiculum: Presumptions and legal arguments in the 12th century. [Medieval law and its practice, 43]. Brill, Leiden – Boston 2025. xvi + 460 S. (Jan Hallebeek)
    • F. Di Chiara, La Praxis inquisitionum, Uno strumento di lavoro nella biblioteca di un erudito siciliano fra XVII e XVIII secolo. Palermo University Press, Palermo 2019. 175 p. (Leen Spruit)
    • B. Kannowski, Geschichte der Menschenrechte. [Wege zur Rechtsgeschichte, utb 6399]. Böhlau, Köln 2025. 476 p. (A.J.B. Sirks)
    Bundels / Recueils / Collections