Search

Showing posts with label History of Criminology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History of Criminology. Show all posts

25 September 2026

BOOK REVIEW: Roberto CATELLO, Crime and civilization: the birth of criminology in the early nineteenth century, by Janne KIVIVOURI (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2024) (Comparative Legal History, XIV (2026), nr. 1 (June), pp. 153-157)

(image source: Taylor&Francis)

Works of critical historiography have long alerted us to the fact that the search for the origins of various academic disciplines, scientific discourses, and strands of thought can be problematic. More often than not, these sorts of historiographic endeavours have failed to historically locate the birth or beginning of their object of study without causing controversy or inviting fierce criticism. Seldomly do the interpretations or reinterpretations of the past produced via these risky academic undertakings result in enthusiastic and unanimous reception by academic audiences and circles. What often happens, instead, is that authors' ideological stances, intellectual biases, and personalised readings of the past are exposed by the authors own efforts to objectively establish what actually happened in the past. Janne Kivivouri's Crime and Civilization: The Birth of Criminology in the Early-nineteenth Century makes an important contribution to the academic study of criminology's past without, however, fully overcoming this historiographic challenge. Kivivouri's overarching argument is that criminology was born in France in the 1820s and 1830s as a scientific, data-driven, quantitative, politically neutral, and state-sanctioned enterprise focused on conventional, street crime - and particularly on the question of how education and civilisation impacted people's morality and criminality. The data revolution enabled by the publication of the French Compte in 1827 ('the first truly modern crime statistical yearbook') gave life, the author argues, to the 'first criminology'. Criminology, defined by Kivivouri as 'systematic analysis of data corpora designed to enable research' (about crime-related phenomena), then, is an early-nineteenth century phenomenon, as the subtitle of the book makes abundantly clear While Kivivouri is not the first to argue that criminologists have been wrong in tracing the origins of modern criminology back to Enlightenment thinkers like Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham, he makes a significant effort in trying to establish why this is so: What separates the first (truly criminological criminology of the early-nineteenth century from the typical ways of thinking about crime from the eighteenth century is 'the systematic use of quantitative data to test hypotheses' […]


To read the full review, please click here. Online access is free for members of the European Society for Comparative Legal History.


DOI: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2049677X.2026.2671632

17 May 2024

CONFERENCE: 'La violenza. Riflessioni interdisciplinari per un dibattito contemporaneo su giustizia, diritto di punire e pena' (Sirolo: Università di Macerata, 24-25 maggio 2024)

 

(Source: Unimc)

Badia San Pietro | Hotel Monteconero | Sirolo (AN)


24 maggio
Introduzione
Angelo Ventrone
/ UNIVERSITÀ DI MACERATA
Quel che viene prima dell’azione: la legittimazione della violenza nella destra rivoluzionaria del ‘900

Alessandro Colombo
/ UNIVERSITÀ DI MILANO
Violenza, politica e diritto nel processo di deistituzionalizzazione della guerra

25 maggio
Valeria Montaruli
/ PRESIDENTE DEL TRIBUNALE PER I MINORENNI DI BARI
Violenza domestica nella narrazione patriarcale tra giustizia e riparazione. Quali prospettive per l’avvenire?

Roberto Bartoli
/ UNIVERSITÀ DI FIRENZE
La violenza e il diritto penale


More information here.

05 May 2022

BOOK: Scott JACQUES, Philip SCHOFIELD (eds.), Jeremy Bentham on Police. The unknown story and what it means for criminology (London: UCL Press, 2021), ISBN: 9781787356177 OPEN ACCESS

(Image source: UCL Press)


ABOUT THE BOOK

Jeremy Bentham’s ideas on punishment are famous. Every criminology student learns about Bentham, and every criminologist contends with him, as advocate or opponent. This discourse concerns his ideas about punishment, namely with respect to legislation and the panopticon. Yet, scholars and students are generally ignorant of Bentham’s ideas on police. Hitherto, these ideas have been largely unknowable. Now, thanks to UCL’s Bentham Project, these ideas are public. Jeremy Bentham on Police celebrates this achievement by exploring the story of Bentham’s writings on police and considering their relevance to the past, present and future of criminology. After Scott Jacques introduces the book, the Director of the Bentham Project, Philip Schofield, describes and explains how it works. Then Michael Quinn, who brought together Bentham’s writings on police, delves into the personal and socio-historical background in which they were created. An extract follows, representing the most (criminologically-)relevant passages from Bentham’s police writings. Finally, a rich variety of scholars offer their thoughts on what those writings mean for criminology. These contributions come from Anthony A. Braga, Ronald Clarke, David J. Cox, Stephen Douglas, Stephen Engelmann, G. Geltner, Joel F. Harrington, Jonathan Jacobs, Paul Knepper, Gloria Laycock, Gary T. Marx, Daniel S. Nagin, Graeme R. Newman, Pat O’Malley, Eric L. Piza, Kim Rossmo, Lucia Summers and Dean Wilson.


ABOUT THE EDITORS

Scott Jacques is Director of Criminology Open, and Professor of Criminal Justice and Criminology at Georgia State University.

Philip Schofield is Director of the Bentham Project, Faculty of Laws, UCL, and General Editor of the new authoritative edition of The Collected Works of Jeremy Bentham.


TABLE OF CONTENTS

Part I: Chapters

1. The Story of Jeremy Bentham on Police: Bridging the Bentham Project to Criminology (Scott Jacques)
2. Jeremy Bentham, the Bentham Project and The Collected Works of Jeremy Bentham (Philip Schofield)
3. Bentham on Preventive Police: The Calendar of Delinquency in Evaluation of Policy, and the Police Gazette in Manipulation of Opinion (Michael Quinn)

Part II: Extracts

4. Extracts from Jeremy Bentham’s Board-of-Police Bill (Jeremy Bentham, Selected and edited by Philip Schofield and Scott Jacques)

Part III: Comments

  • The Influence of Bentham on the Development of Focused Deterrence (Anthony A. Braga and Stephen Douglas)
  • Regulating Crime and the International Crime Drop (Ronald Clarke)
  • ‘An Attention to Domestic Quiet’: A Comparative Commentary on the Originality or Otherwise of Bentham’s Views and Writings on Preventive Policing and the Police Gazette (David J. Cox)
  • Bentham’s Virtue (Stephen Engelmann)
  • On Policing Before Bentham: Differences in Degree and Differences in Kind (G. Geltner)
  • Bentham’s England and the Longue Durée of Preventive Policing (Joel F. Harrington)
  • Bentham on the Complex Role of Police (Jonathan Jacobs)
  • Bentham and Historical Criminology (Paul Knepper)
  • Bentham: The First Crime Scientist? Gloria Laycock)
  • Bentham on Modern Social Control: Prescient, Clairvoyant, Prescient, and More (Gary T. Marx)
  • Utilitarianism and Policing in the US (Daniel S. Nagin)
  • Bentham in the Weeds (Graeme R. Newman)
  • A Genealogy of Bentham’s Preventive Policing (Pat O’Malley)
  • Bentham on Crime Analysis and Evidence-Based Policing (Eric L. Piza)
  • Bentham and the Philosophical Nature of Preventive Policing (Kim Rossmo and Lucia Summers)
  • Bentham in the Colonies (Dean Wilson)


More information can be found here. The entire publication can be read and downloaded at this link.