Jewish turns to law – whether as a profession, a means of social mobility and integration, or a venue where emancipatory claims could be formulated or put forward to negotiate the challenges of modernity – remain largely unexplored in legal-historical research. There is no denying the rich insights displayed by biographies, prosopographies, institutional histories, and works focusing on particular case studies written over the past three decades or so; yet browsing through the catalogues of Jewish personal or institutional archives recording the past two centuries reveals that this richness serves to obfuscate many more lives (in particular of those who have not reached the status of luminaries), associations, foci of advocacy, legal strategies, court cases, or lawmaking enterprises. At the same time, studies of Jewish legal responses to the rise of National Socialism have recently inclined towards international law, international institutions, and international advocacy action. While certain episodes of Jewish legal activism at the national level are well-documented, many others remain under-researched (9).David Fraser’s meticulously researched comparative legal history represents an important contribution to these lacunas in the extant literature. It narrates not only a range of what may be described as Jewish ‘legal self-defence’ across various jurisdictions but also how Jewish individuals and institutions communicated across national borders to share information, knowledge and advice when responding to the rise of the antisemitism of the 1930s. Throughout the book, action and reaction are juxtaposed to frame Jewish legal advocacy as a local, but also inter- and trans-national, response to a local and inter- and trans-national threat. To that end, Fraser first carefully recreates the thick socio-political contexts, discourses, and imaginations of Catholic police officers, conservative nationalists, journalists, army veterans, fringe and mainstream politicians, and professionals of the ‘Antisemitic international’ (11) to foreground a ‘socio-legal comparative history of … Jewish attempts in the 1930s “Anglosphere” to counter the rise in fascist and Nazi antisemitism’ (1). To that end, the first two chapters (2–3) provide a convenient, compact comparative survey of some of the features of the ‘Antisemitic international’: its tropes, texts – in particular, the Protocols of the Elders of Zion – German ties, circulation, agents, the networks they formed, and their modus operandi. These chapters also reflect on the challenges, choices, and pitfalls of Jewish legal resistance in jurisdictions outside the Anglosphere.
Search
17 October 2025
BOOK REVIEW: Rotem GILADI on Nazi antisemitism and Jewish legal self-defense: the turn to law in liberal democracies, 1932–39 by David Fraser (Comparative Legal History, XIII (2025), nr. 1 (June), pp. 169-173)
13 September 2023
BOOK: David FRASER, Nazi Antisemitism and Jewish Legal Self-defense: The Turn to Law in Liberal Democracies, 1932-39 [Routledge Studies in Comparative Legal History] (London: Routledge, 2023), 324 p. ISBN 9781032520100, £ 130
(Image source: Routledge)
ABOUT THE BOOK
One of the first to provide a socio-legal comparative history of under-studied or ignored Jewish attempts in the 1930s "Anglosphere" to counter the rise in fascist and Nazi antisemitism, this book examines the ways in which Jewish individuals and organized communal bodies in the mid-to-late 1930s sought to counter this increasing antisemitic violence, physical and verbal, by using the law against their fascist and Nazi attackers.
This is the first study to explore how Jews in these countries organized themselves, brought their oppressors to court, while seeking to convince their governments that an attack on Jews was a threat to the social order. The book analyzes the networks of knowledge and the personal relationships between and among key actors and institutions of the "Antisemitic International." Nazi "nationalists" always participated in networks that transcended borders. Case studies from Canada, South Africa, the United Kingdom, and the United States, illustrate the ways in which different mechanisms of Jewish resistance were deployed throughout the mid-to-late 1930s. They embody significant concerns about the "turn to law" and the importance of litigation and legislation. Grounded in original archival research on three continents, the book examines the ways in which professional legal discourse about public order and democratic citizenship proffered by Jewish communities and individual Jews was countered by their Nazi opponents with legal and political arguments about "truth," "persecution," and Jewish perfidy.
The book will be of interest to students, academics, and researchers working in the areas of Legal History, History, Jewish Studies, the study of Antisemitism, and the History of the far right, fascism and Nazism.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Jews, Nazis, and the Turn to Law
2. The Antisemitic International: The Protocols and Jewish-Legal Self-defense
3. Europe: Jewish legal Self-defense as an International Phenomenon
4. The Greyshirts Trial: Jews, Nazis, and Legal Self-defense in South Africa
5. After the Greyshirts Trial: Jewish Self-defense in South Africa following the Victory of Rabbi Levy
6. Jews, Nazis, and the Québec Experience: The Failures of Law
7. Canadian Nazis and Jewish Legal Self-defense in Manitoba: Tobias v. Whittaker
8. The Freiman-Tissot Affair; Nazis Antisemites, Jews, and the Canadian Criminal Code
9. Nazi Antisemitism, Jewish legal Self-defense, and Criminal Libel in Ottawa
10. Nazi Antisemites, Libel Suits, and Jewish Legal Self-defense in the United States
11. The Edmondson Case and the Trial That Wasn’t: American Antisemitism, American Law, American Jews
12. English Jewish Self-defense: Elites, Masses, and Law
13. The Leese Case: Libel Laws, Nazi Antisemites, and Jewish Self-defense in England
14. Conclusion: Beyond Jewish Legal Self-defense?
More information can be found here.
