Search

Showing posts with label American Journal of Legal History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American Journal of Legal History. Show all posts

30 March 2026

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History (vol. LXIV)


(image source: OUP)

This blog has not reported anymore on the American Journal of Legal History since June 2024. Here is an overview of the material published since:

Advance articles

Jury riders as jury power in twentieth-century England (Kay Crosby) [OPEN ACCESS]
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njaf009
Abstract:

This article argues that the relatively obscure practice of jury riders and recommendations reveals a historic political role for juries which has hitherto gone unnoticed. In short, riders mattered as a community intervention into the work of both judges and of local government. This article draws on over 1000 verdicts, both in criminal courts and in coroners’ courts, from England and Wales, 1900 to 1999. In recent work unearthing the existence of jury riders, Coen and Howlin principally sought to reveal what was said by juries in addition to their formal verdicts; this article focuses on what these observations were for. This shift in focus reveals that the type of jury had significance not only for what the jury said, but also for how it was received. Where a coroner’s jury offered a rider, it was a means for informal rebuke, with no definite, automatic outcome (although local authorities often felt compelled to respond). There was power in this sort of pronouncement, but it was often quite diffuse. Riders from trial juries were very different. Here, the statement added to the verdict was much more likely to be a formal recommendation for mercy. Trial juries were probably less free to set out their views in detail, but their words had more formal power, feeding directly (albeit only normally as part of a wider picture) into the sentencing decisions of judges. But while the precise power of a jury’s words changed from one context to another, it was a consistently powerful, often political intervention.

(1) LXIV/4 (December 2024)

Mr Locke’s enclosure: the uncommon law of property in the Second Treatise (Hannah Carrese)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njaf008
Abstract:

John Locke, famously, told a property origin story. This article tells a property theory origin story, asking how Locke’s property theory, which omits common rights, emerged from a common law of property that centred them—and showing how this omission influenced the colonial American law that Locke drafted. Locke was silent on or rejected the common law of property, which recognized common rights and defences against privatization of commons through enclosure. Instead, Locke adopted law reform arguments lauding enclosure because it improved waste land. Locke’s property theory therefore attempts to improve the common law of property by orienting it around private rather than common property. He asks a question about the origin of property absent from common law: how do we create private rights to common land? He takes ‘waste’ to have purely negative connotations, avoiding the neutral meanings of that word at common law. And he stipulates that enclosure of English commons requires only tacit consent of commoners, excluding common law defences against enclosure. Locke’s is an equal opportunity enclosure. His spoilage principle and plan to reform Virginia’s land laws sought to benefit the poor by preventing vast enclosures and rural depopulation. However, he theorized a clean chain of title, absent in common law, which could prevent messy disputes over wealthy estates. This article shows the common law background from which Locke departed, thus deepening understanding of both our private property regime, often justified by Locke’s property theory, and a sometimes-overlooked alternative to it, the common law of property.

The laws of ‘an old and settled society’? The law of contract in New South Wales 1815–1850 (Warren Swain) [OPEN ACCESS]
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njaf007
Abstract:

The history of contract law in New South Wales in the decades after the closure of the Court of Civil Jurisdiction in 1814 has not received much attention from legal historians. This is an important omission. At the heart of this story is a simple but critical inquiry: the way in which the law of contract in the colony mirrored or diverged from the law of contract that applied back in London. This was rarely a matter that judges addressed explicitly. Piecing together the relationship is an exercise in reconstruction. This can only be done by examining the body of case law. The creation of the Australasian Colonial Legal History Library, combined with readily searchable newspaper reports, has made this easier. The evidence in the mid-nineteenth century is still sometimes sketchy. Context is relevant. The colony moved from a quasi-military penal colony to a significant hub of commercial activity. The period also saw a shift in the legal system as the old informal systems evolved into a much more legalistic one. For the most part, New South Wales contract law was aligned with that in England. Some issues, like the desertion of sailors demanded local solutions. There are other examples in which well-established English contract doctrine did not necessarily fit very well with the conditions of the colony.

Who is a central bank for? The founding and legal design of the Bank of Canada (Dan Rohde)[OPEN ACCESS]
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njaf004 
Abstract:

The Bank of Canada is an independent Crown corporation that sees its primary responsibility to be promoting Canada’s economic welfare by maintaining low and stable inflation. When it was first created in 1934, however, the Bank was a radically different institution—a privately owned corporation primarily meant to anchor Canada’s economy globally and manage foreign exchange. Not only was the Bank not tasked with managing inflation, but key policymakers behind its founding thought doing so would be a severe mistake. This article offers the first legal history of the Bank’s founding. It maps the enormous public debate that accompanied the creation of the Bank and the various, often contradictory visions expressed for it. The article labels these five visions: a Bankers’ Bank, a Government Bank, an Imperial Bank, an Economists’ Bank, and a Bank of the People. The article then looks at the original legal design of the Bank and argues that it largely fit the Imperial Bank model. Charting this history helps us better understand this vital organ of Canadian government, and has the potential to upset many of our accepted, contemporary notions of central banking.

 (2) LXIV/3 (September 2024)

Early American versions of a homosexual-advances defence (William B. Meyer)
DOI  10.1093/ajlh/njaf002
Abstract:

Homicide suspects in the United States have sometimes maintained, and prosecutors and juries have sometimes agreed, that their crimes were less serious or were justified entirely if they were responding to homosexual advances by their victims. Studies of such a defence’s use have, with a single exception from 1868, been confined to the period after 1920. A newspaper search, modelled on one used to explore another supposed ‘unwritten law’, identifies nine additional instances between the Civil War and 1914. In the most notable of them, the murder of Joseph Frye in Boston in 1879, such advances were all but explicitly recognized as constituting legal provocation that mitigated the crime. In this and other cases, a credible invocation of the defence seems to have lightened the killer’s punishment when any was imposed.

Litigating longshoremen in the Lone Star State: black dock workers and the struggle to maintain autonomy after the 1964 Civil Rights Act (D. Caleb Smith)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njaf003
Abstract:

On 20 January 1969, the Department of Justice (DOJ) filed suit against 37 International Longshoremen’s Association (ILA) locals in 10 Texas cities. The DOJ charged that the ILA was in violation of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. In United States v International Longshoremen’s Association, the government attacked the segregated union structure found throughout the state’s waterfronts and condemned a long history of racial bias. In Texas, black dock workers made up two-thirds of ILA membership, but got fewer than half of the total work assignments. Black longshoremen both leaned on the law and defied it. For almost two decades, they refused to merge with white locals, but filed federal complaints to gain fair employment. This article argues that the struggle to maintain separatism while advocating for equality at ILA waterfronts was an effort to gain an unattainable workplace freedom by insisting on upholding a century-long tradition of biracial cooperation that was at the root of economic injustice, but at the cornerstone of an indispensable moral value and black sustainability.

The progressive secularization of credit in New Granada and the antecedents of commercial banking in Colombia (1835–1863) (Marcela Castro-Ruiz)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njaf005
Abstract:

In the initial years of the republican era, New Granada (now Colombia) underwent a profound transformation in its sources and mechanisms of credit, transitioning from the predominance of a spiritual economy during the colonial period to a secular system that gradually evolved into a banking framework by the late nineteenth century. Starting in the mid-1830s, influenced by liberal ideology, a combination of factors catalysed this evolution, including the liberalization of interest rates, the establishment of savings institutions, and intellectual discourse surrounding the need to organize a formal banking system. Despite several attempts to establish an institutionalized financial framework, only in the 1860s and 1870s did the federal government ultimately foster the formation of regional banks. This article serves as an introduction to comprehend the origins and progression of the Colombian banking system.

The State of Florida v Fortune Ferguson, Jr: the death penalty and legal change in Florida, 1924–1927 (Brandon J. Tett) 
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njaf006
Abstract:

This article uses the case of Fortune Ferguson, Jr to explore the creation and effects of the creation of a centralized justice system in Florida in the 1920s. This involved a 16-year-old Black teenager accused, convicted, and executed for rape in Florida in the mid-1920s. This represented the first person sentenced to die in the newly created electric chair in Florida’s state prison. The shift to the electric chair and state-run executions reflected a larger move by the legislature to remove criminal justice processes from the decentralized system that existed prior to 1923. This system vested significant authority in the community, local officials, and private contractors. But that system came under significant strain by the 1910s and 1920s. The shift to the electric chair and state executions emerged out of the larger critiques of the decentralized justice system. As such, this case reflects an effort to establish the authority of the new centralized system, as it was one of the first cases to be tried in it. The transition to state-run private executions was not as disadvantageous to local officials as scholars have suggested. Instead of framing the centralization of criminal justice processes as a competition between state and local criminal justice actors, the case of Fortune Ferguson provides insight into the collaborative efforts that occurred between state and local officials that augmented the authority of formal agents of criminal justice at both the state and local levels.

Book review: Hendrik Hartog, Nobody’s Boy and His Pals: The Story of Jack Robbins and the Boys’ Brotherhood Republic (Kathryn Schumaker)

(3) LXIV/2 (June 2024)

Comparative legal teaching in eighteenth-century Oxford: an analysis of Thomas Bever’s Appendix to his lectures (Łukasz Jan Korporowicz) [OPEN ACCESS]
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njae013 
Abstract:

In the 1760s and 1770s, Thomas Bever, a once-eminent but today nearly-forgotten English civilian, was delivering a course of lectures devoted to civil law at Oxford. The final part of those lectures, known as the Appendix, was of a different character from the earlier parts. In the Appendix Bever discussed the development of the law and constitution of 15 European countries. His description was an attempt to compare different systems and to abstract general legal concepts common to different countries. Along with other issues, Bever was specifically interested in abstracting the common roots of medieval feudalism. The analysis offered in this article is the result of archival investigation comparing two different versions of Bever’s lecture notes. The main objective of the article is to reconstruct Bever’s narrative, together with analysing his methodology and the intellectual framework of his work. This investigation reveals the intricacies of the legal education offered at Oxford in the second half of the eighteenth century.

Medical dominance and the law: European medical exiles in Tasmania, 1933–1951 (Gabrielle Wolf)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njae012
Abstract:

Doctors who escaped Nazi-occupied Europe and immigrated to Australia were greeted mostly with hostility by representatives of the local medical profession. Australian doctors agitated for amendment of legislation that governed registration of medical practitioners in each state, so that it removed any legal entitlement of the European medical exiles to practise medicine. Tasmania’s Parliament was the first Australian legislature to accede to these medical practitioners’ pressure, and did so before the Second World War began. This article explores reasons for both the particular eagerness of the Tasmanian medical profession to prevent the émigrés from practising medicine and its capacity to achieve its objective so quickly. This analysis provides a case study of how doctors attempted to use licensing laws to entrench the dominance of the medical profession.

Étienne Parent, the Demise of the Mixed Constitution, and the Rise of Liberalism of Government in French Canada (Jean-Christophe Bédard-Rubin) [OPEN ACCESS]
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njae009
Abstract:

Between the adoption of the Act of Union in 1840 and the British North America Act in 1867, French-Canadian elites had to reconceptualize the nature and virtues of the British constitutional system. Étienne Parent, an early defender of the ‘mixed constitution’ and one of the most influential thinkers among French-Canadian reformists, turned to the civil service to give the new constitutional regime a stable foundation. His theory of the ‘sovereignty of intelligence’ borrowed French liberal ideas to build a distinct model of constitutionalism out of British constitutional institutions. Parent’s thought also exemplifies how the idea that the constitution is the principal integrative force of the polity continued to shape French-Canadian constitutional imaginary in the mid-nineteenth century. Recovering this dynamic and historical approach to constitutionalism sheds light on this distinct constitutional model, obscured by the later influence of AV Dicey and his retrospective interpretation of nineteenth-century constitutionalism. Putting the emphasis on the administration, Parent’s theory of the ‘sovereignty of intelligence’ offered a form of government liberalism which differed from the liberalism associated with parliamentary sovereignty, and republicanism and popular sovereignty. In many respects, Parent participated directly in the consolidation of the constitutional model he defended, and his thought allows us to recapture the synergy and generative tension between the cabinet and the civil service that endures in the contemporary constitutional practices of Westminster parliamentary systems.

Sect and Superstition: The Protestant Framework of American Codification (Kellen R. Funk) [OPEN ACCESS]
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njae008
Abstract:

Elite lawyers who debated codification in the nineteenth-century United States treated codification as inseparable from a liberal Protestant textualism that had taken hold in the early national era. Legislators declared codification to be the necessary final step of the Protestant Reformation and frequently characterized common law lawyers as beholden to ‘superstition’ and ‘priestcraft’. Their opponents denounced the codifiers’ idea that texts alone could adequately convey common meanings and delighted to point out the endlessly fracturing glosses on supposedly ‘clear’ texts that divided the positivists into an ever-increasing number of sects. Many works have addressed the relationship between populism and positivism over the course of the codification debates in the United States. What these works have missed is the Protestantism. Understanding how lawyers of another generation approached these questions can help us to appreciate the varieties of American textualism, and the fact that today’s textualism may be as foreign to textualisms of the past as to other methods entirely. Rather than the forerunners of a modern, rationalist ‘Republic of Statutes’, the codifiers were the literal and figurative sons of a post-Calvinist generation that was unquenchably optimistic about the clarity of texts and the common sense of individuals reading them. This lens also helps us better understand the defenders of the common law, who were not so much the retrograde servants of property rights and judicial supremacy as they are often presented, but were more often practically minded lawyers who understood the limits to which legislative texts could change the complex practices of law on the ground.

Book reviews:

  •  Omar Valerio-Jiménez, Remembering Conquest: Mexican Americans, Memory, and Citizenship (Scott D. Wagner)
  • Christian G Fritz, Monitoring American Federalism: The History of State Legislative Resistance (Jane Manners)
  • On Constitutional Romance and Federalisms Long Forgotten: A Review Essay (Aaron Hall)
  • Dylan C. Penningroth, Before the Movement: The Hidden History of Black Civil Rights (Andrew J Lanham)
  • Anthony Gregory, New Deal Law and Order: How the War on Crime Built the Modern Liberal State (Matthew Denney)
Read more with OUP.


04 April 2024

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History LXIII (2023), No. 4 (Dec)

 

(image source: OUP)

The Abolition of the Right to Trial by Jury in Civil Cases in England (Charles S. Bullock)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad028

Abstract:

Prior to 1854, jury trial was the exclusive mode of resolving cases involving disputed facts at common law. By 1935, the civil jury trial had been virtually eliminated in all but a few obscure types of tort action. This article consists of a detailed examination, based primarily on legislative sources and contemporary legal periodicals, of how the right to trial by jury in civil cases was abolished. The first concrete step towards jury abolition occurred in 1854, when litigants in high court cases were empowered to waive their right to jury trial in favour of trial by judge alone. Thereafter, a series of legislative acts and judicial rules incrementally transferred the power to choose the mode of trial in particular types of cases from litigants to trial judges, who routinely chose trial by judge alone.

Brave New World? Care and Custody of Cildren at the Court for Divorce and Matrimonial Causes in Mid-Victorian England (Penelope Russell)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad029

Abstract:

This article considers the accessibility and impact of the mid-Victorian divorce court’s new custody powers, by tracing the children of those who petitioned the court within the first two years of the court’s establishment and contrasting this with court pleadings and orders. Focusing on the care of children by location as revealed by the census and other sources, this study then deals in more detail with individual cases to illustrate the experience of parties in divorce court processes for child custody. This study generates an original data set to find that, whereas the majority of resident female petitioners sought a custody order in the petition, only a minority ended up with an order. Three broad issues are addressed: the gendered nature of rights in respect of children on marital breakdown, the implications of legal remedies being accessed through male gatekeepers, and the exercise of discretion at the newly opened divorce court.

Banking Law in Italian Legal Consulting between the Fourteenth and the Fifteenth Centuries (Mario Conetti)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad027

Abstract:

Banking operations in northern and central Italy between late fourteenth and early fifteenth century were very sophisticated and often gave rise to disputes involving the expertise only law professors could provide. To provide solutions which were at the same time viable and grounded in legal culture, lawyers went beyond merely practical considerations to work out legal institutions as a framework to banking activities. In doing so, they developed a proper banking law, a peculiar legal system.

In forma pauperis: Indentured Servitude, the Right to Counsel, and White Citizenship in the Seventeenth-Century Chesapeake (Anna Suranyi)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad024

Abstract:

Indentured servitude was an exploitative form of coerced labor in England’s American colonies, but indentured servants were expected to join settler society after completing their terms of indenture, and they possessed clearly defined legal rights and protections in both English and colonial laws, even during their period of servitude. The masters and mistresses of indentured servants sometimes engaged in physical abuse and contractual fraud, but servants could sue their masters or mistresses in court without owing fees, a status termed in forma pauperis. Courts facilitated servant lawsuits and heeded procedural fairness, bringing in compensated witnesses, searching archival records, and even providing pro bono lawyers. It appears that most servants won their cases against their masters and mistresses, obtaining their freedom, their withheld freedom dues, or reimbursement for overlong terms of servitude. Indentured servants’ lawyers affirmed that their clients were rights-bearing members of society, persuasively utilizing terms such as ‘justice’ and ‘equity’ to represent their cases. The access of servants to legal recourse, the courts’ commitment to ensure due process and legal representation, and the frequent victories of servants over their masters demonstrated that indentured servants were regarded as valued members of colonial society in the Chesapeake, and in other colonial regions. Unlike enslaved people, who possessed neither legal rights nor access to the courts, white indentured servants possessed inherent, though limited, rights of freeborn subjects, even if from disenfranchised groups, such as women, children, or those of Irish origin. The legal and social distinctions between servitude and slavery began arising half a century before Bacon’s Rebellion in the 1670s, which is conventionally assumed to be a watershed event in the division between indentured servitude and slavery. The affirmation of the rights of indentured servants developed in parallel with the growth of slavery, and contributed to developing ideals of white citizenship.

Justice Kennedy’s Jurisprudence of Dignity: From Sovereign Immunity to Gay Rights
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad026

Abstract:

Although this article uses Obergefell v Hodges (2015) as its frame, it aims to bring out some distinctive features of Justice Kennedy’s jurisprudence of dignity more broadly. There are two reasons why such an investigation is important. The first is important to those interested in the legal case. Indeed, in Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health (2022), the Court now argues that the relevant ‘test’ for determining whether a right is protected under the Due Process Clause is whether the right is found to be ‘deeply rooted’ in the nation’s history and tradition. This article aims to critique this decision, as well as originalist approaches to constitutional interpretation more broadly, and seeks to resurrect and reconstruct Kennedy’s jurisprudence of dignity that has undergirded (sometimes quietly) the expansion of civil rights protections to the LGBTQ+ community. The second reason this investigation is important is of interest to philosophers and legal historians. Dignity is a notoriously elusive concept, and much ink has been spilt trying to sort out the precise nature of its content and its boundaries. This article brings together the many (seemingly disparate) uses of dignity found across cases involving gay rights, abortion, and foreign sovereign immunity, and argues Kennedy effectively weaves these uses together in ways that may sharpen our understanding of dignity in both the philosophical and legal literatures.

Hoist by the Colonizer’s Own Device? Law Reporting in Mandatory Palestine (Yair Sagy & Eyal Katvan)
DOI  10.1093/ajlh/njad014

Abstract:

This article tells the history of the Palestine Law Reports series (PLR), introduced in 1934 to Mandate-ruled Palestine. It unearths discussions that preceded the PLR’s publications following a campaign for authorized law reporting launched by lawyers in Palestine in the 1920s to 1930s. Canvassing a broad institutional context for the emergence of the PLR, we argue that in launching the campaign local lawyers sought not only to render Palestinian common law more predictable and amenable to professional handling, but also to approximate the role granted in the metropole and the common law tradition to practicing lawyers in propagating binding precedents. Local lawyers wanted to have a slice of the action of creating a local common law and in designing the Palestinian legal landscape. Unsurprisingly, they were met with the opposition of Chief Justice McDonnell, who sought to control the PLR enterprise, resisting non-judicial involvement in its editing and production. Finally, the article argues that, regardless of McDonnell’s motivations, from an institutional point of view, his achievement in laying down a foundational institution for the generation of a local common law is momentous. He therefore emerges from our analysis as one of the chief architects of the common law in Palestine, and—to this day—in Israel.

International Legacies of a Century and a Half of the Case Method (Han-Ru Zhou)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad025

Abstract:

Save the Constitution, the United States’s most famous legal export may well be the case method. This article pieces together the story of how CC Langdell’s brainchild was brought to the rest of the common law world in treading the momentous events and geopolitics of the last century and a half, and reflects on the lessons from this global experiment for the present and future of the case method. After initially attracting little attention overseas, the rise of the case method encountered its watershed in the post-war period. From then on, the method’s further expansion branched into two narratives: one in the Western world and the other in the former British African, Asian, and Caribbean colonies. The overseas experiments with the case method yielded some durable successes and cast a light on its singular ability to adapt to widely different environments. But mostly the picture is one of mixed results, especially outside the Western world, owing to a failure to devise an educational program adapted to the varying local circumstances. As with law itself, the teaching of law is inextricably tied to local idiosyncrasies and world politics, thus making the future of the case method as difficult to predict as it would have been for Langdell and his contemporaries. Today’s different national and international contexts from that of 1945 represent an opportunity to reassess the merits of the case method in our more mature legal and educational environments, freed from colonial and neocolonial agendas.

 Read the full issue here.

21 November 2023

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History LXIII (2023), No. 2

 

(image source: OUP)

SPECIAL SYMPOSIUM ISSUE: STATUS IN ANCIENT AND MEDIEVAL LAW

Status in Ancient and Medieval Law: Introduction (Timothy Lubin)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad018
Abstract:

Legal systems past and present classify people in ways that entail particular rights, obligations, capacities, and incapacities. Historically, statuses have distinguished between free, freed, and unfree; citizen and alien (and statuses in between); membership in legally recognized religious, ethnic, tribal, or racial groups; marital and other family statuses (spouse, divorcee, dependent, heir, etc.); and many others. Henry Sumner Maine, the nineteenth-century comparative legal historian, proposed that ‘the movement of the progressive societies has hitherto been a movement from Status to Contract’.1 He envisaged history, at least in the West, as a progressive detachment of individual rights and capacities from the involuntary, inherited statuses connected with family and tribe. Yet in spite of a trend toward liberal individualism in modern secular states, status distinctions still permeate law, though they are usually conceived of and discussed in narrowly circumscribed, compartmentalized forms: status of citizen, immigrant, or alien; minor, dependent, or adult; married or domestic partner; heir; corporate person; member of the military or the clergy; and ‘personal status’ under various colonial or postcolonial regimes. It is rare to see anyone address in broad terms the continuing salience of status in modern Anglo-American legal contexts, though there are exceptions.

Empire, Status, and the Law (Clifford Ando)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad019
Abstract:

One phase in the long history of Roman citizenship ended in 212 CE, when the emperor Caracalla granted citizenship to all free-born residents of the empire. This moment subsequently came to be understood as inevitable, as though the juridical unification of the world had been the project of empire all along—and virtually all subsequent European empires have been implicated in the legacy of that tradition. But the history of Roman citizenship is neither unitary nor continuous. This article interrogates processes of juridification in the relationship between citizenship and empire. Some of these concern the Roman citizen body itself, which on one reading was gradually transformed from a collective of self-ruling agents to a community of economic actors. Others concern the effects on alien political and religious communities of the appearance of Roman tribunals as courts of the second instance. The legacies of Roman citizenship in modern forms of subjectivity should be understood against this complex history.

Metics and Freedmen: Conflicts of Social and Juridical Status in the Classical and Hellenistic Greek World (Elizabeth A Meyer)
DOI  10.1093/ajlh/njad020
Abstract:

Ancient Greek city-states, or poleis, had a bewildering number of terms for people who lived in them. In Athens, freedmen seem to be assimilated juridically to the status of metics (resident aliens), although socially there were ways of both denigrating freedmen and obscuring the distinction between metic and freed. Elsewhere we can see that under some circumstances distinctions between metic and freed were made, but not in ways that point to strong juridical differences. By looking at the development of both statuses historically, I propose that the juridical assimilation occurred in Athens because metic status was created first, in an historical context in which distinctions between citizens and foreigners was crucial: an imperial power with a strong economy was attracting many foreigners to the mother city. This line drawn between citizens and foreigners was expressed through the law in both the fifth and fourth centuries BCE. But the social perception of metics changed in the fourth century, for historical reasons deriving from the assimilation of metics and freed into one category. Other areas of the Greek world with both metics and freedmen may have assimilated the two statuses initially, but over time split them apart.

Religious Endowments in Ancient India and the Institutionalization of Brahmin Caste Status (Timothy Lubin)
DOI  10.1093/ajlh/njad023
Abstract:

Giving to worthy recipients has been meritorious public piety in India at least since the Mauryan empire. Most consequential were grants in perpetuity of land or capital as a ‘religious foundation’ for monks or Brahmins, conferred by means of a charter (śāsana). Grants to Brahmins typically created or supported an agrahāra, a residential enclave with attached farmland and villages, on terms analogous to those of grants to Buddhist or Jaina mendicants or monasteries. In these records (attested since the beginning of the Common Era), rulers cede their claims to certain normal obligations of subjects, such as tax revenue, compulsory labor, and billeting or provisions for officers of the state, and they often give the beneficiaries authority over internal legal administration. This article examines the implications of the fiscal and juridical autonomy conferred in such grants in providing state recognition and institutional support of Brahmins’ sacred status as a religious profession and a privileged caste.

Belief as Status: Premodern Islamic Law, Duties, and the Martyr Conundrum (Adnan A. Zulfiqar)
DOI  10.1093/ajlh/njad022
Abstract:

The normative universe of the premodern Islamic legal tradition revolves around duties. These duties are determined by an individual’s status both as an autonomous entity and as part of the collective. The duties one owes and those that one is owed, are primarily constructed around belief. Belief, and its absence, function as the primary vehicles for affirming or denying an individual’s place within the moral community. In the jurists discourse on warfare, during the fifth AH/eleventh CE and sixth AH/twelfth CE centuries, we find an illustrative example of how belief dictates the duties that must be performed. Who is obligated to fight, who must be fought, and what obligations are owed in death all depend, though not exclusively, on the belief status of the relevant actors. In the process jurists constructed status hierarchies based on belief and, as in the case of martyrs, negotiated a delicate balance between preserving the sacredness of belief status and accounting for the pragmatic requirements of the battlefield.

The Matter of Personae in Medieval Italy (Melissa Vise)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad021
Abstract:

This article hunts for the medieval understanding of juridical persona in the courtrooms of communal Italy (c.1250–1450). While corporate personae have been the long-favored subject of inquiry for both medieval and modern scholars, the ontological predecessor of the corporate persona, the juridical persona, remains undertheorized. The gap is surprising given that (i) the concept is central to other formative legal notions of standing, status, and identity and (ii) medieval legal practice’s erstwhile penchant was to gloss and re-gloss every word of its central texts. By considering cases of gestural blasphemy brought before both civic and ecclesiastical courts, this article discovers the multiple and context-specific meanings for persona at law. These shifting definitions hover around a theological impossibility: a material quality to divine persons that could render them subject to injury and defendable in court. I contend that the legal utility of the term persona rested in its ability to bridge conceptual gaps like that created in the prosecution of blasphemy. Persona was left definitionally both one and many for good legal reason.

ARTICLE

‘Our Practice Has a Superiority:’ Debt Enforcement, Bills of Exchange, and Credit in Eighteenth-Century Glasgow (Hunter Harris)
DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad011
Abstract:

This article explores the relationship between the Scots law of bills of exchange, debt enforcement procedures, and credit in the eighteenth century. Compared to England, Scots law’s procedures for recovering debts on obligations were faster, cheaper, and more efficient. These legal provisions are under-appreciated in the current literature on bills of exchange. Scots law’s superiority meant that the provision of medium-value credit in urban economies often occurred through written obligations. Using a new archival data set of nearly 300 bills of exchange from Glasgow, this article demonstrates how Glaswegians used those instruments. It finds that elements of the law of obligations traditionally stressed in the literature, namely negotiability, do little to explain the use of credit instruments in Glasgow. Instead, it was Scots law’s quick recovery procedures that account for their patterns of use. The data shows that inland bills did not commonly pass from hand to hand but instead were held as proofs of debt that could quickly be enforced. The advantage of Scots law in this area did not go unnoticed by contemporaries, and unsuccessful attempts at legal reform in the Victorian era sought to introduce the Scottish rules to the English system. This article joins a growing literature in turning scholarly focus away from the negotiable properties of bills, and shows the importance of expedited enforcement procedures for understanding the Scots credit system. It suggests that paying closer attention to procedural law and differences between jurisdictions can advance research agendas on the relationship between law and economic development.

BOOK REVIEWS

  •  Eric L Muller, Lawyer, Jailer, Ally, Foe: Complicity and Conscience in America’s World War II Concentration Camps (Gabriel J. Chin)
  • Brent Salter, Negotiating Copyright in the American Theatre: 1856–1951 (Oren Bracha)
Read the full issue with Oxford Journals.

10 April 2023

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History LXII (2022), No. 4

 

(image source: OUP)


Those Things Which Are Written in Romance: Language and Law Teaching in Thirteenth-Century  England (Thomas J McSweeney) (DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njac020)

Abstract:
Around 1250, a shift began to occur in texts written on the common law. Where earlier texts on the practices of the king’s courts had mostly been written in Latin, a number of the new texts written after 1250 were written in French. The shift to French initially occurred mostly in the context of texts on counting and pleading, the oral parts of court procedure, which were conducted in French, and one author of the 1280s even suggested that by his time a norm had developed that texts on counting and pleading should be written in French. This article examines the evidence for such a norm and the reasons for the shift to French in the later thirteenth century. It uses texts on counting and pleading to examine how both French and Latin were used in the education of pleaders and concludes that, although a norm probably did exist that the oral parts of procedure should be taught in French, Latin was still being used for a number of different purposes in the education of pleaders.

Charitable Trusts of Cemeteries and Places of Worship in Thailand: A Historical Anomaly (Surutchada Reekie) (DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njac022)

Abstract:

This article examines Thailand’s historic charitable trusts for the purpose of establishing and maintaining cemeteries and places of worship. Whilst existing literature explores the reception of English trusts law in British colonial territories in Southeast Asia over the course of nineteenth century, little is discussed in relation to Thailand, historically known as Siam, during the same period. Based on the author’s archival research, this article explores the route and development of these trusts and argues that, due to the Thai Supreme Court’s recognition of their charitable purpose, these trusts are not subject to a rule against perpetuities. Therefore, they will continue to present an anomalous exception to Thailand’s civil law legal framework and offer a fascinating example of the deep, tenacious roots put down by a rejected legal concept from Thailand’s brush with nineteenth century colonial powers. 

The Tragic Pragmatism of the Wagner Act (Daniel Judt) (DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njac019)

Abstract:

The Wagner Act established a right to collective action as the keystone of industrial democracy. In doing so, it also articulated a radical conception of the self: that individuals form genuine desires and attain full self-actualization through collective action. This conception ran counter to the traditional liberal idea of selfhood, which took possessive individualism as the fundament of democratic governance. This paper places the Wagner Act and its reception in the context of changing conceptions of the self in American political thought from 1920 to 1950. The Wagner Act derived its conception of democratic activity from a pragmatist and progressivist theory of the “social self.” But its reception took place amidst a very different intellectual context. By midcentury, a liberal hostility to “mass society” and its deleterious effects on individual choice had repudiated the older pragmatist collectivism. In other words, the Act’s core provision—the notion of collective action as central to the formation of workers’ individual desires—was born of a dying moment in American thought. The immediate hostility that the new labor law regime faced in Congress and the courts was a consequence, in part, of that disjuncture.

O’Connor v Donaldson (1975): Legal Challenges, Psychiatric Authority, and the Dangerousness Problem in Deinstitutionalization (Laura Hirshbein) (DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njad002) 

Abstract:

In 1975, the Supreme Court heard the case of O’Connor v Donaldson, in which Kenneth Donaldson disputed the decision of his psychiatrists at the Florida State Hospital to keep him incarcerated for 15 years for a mental illness, though he was not dangerous or receiving treatment. The Donaldson decision pitted activist attorneys against psychiatrists who were increasingly beleaguered in their efforts to assert expertise about mental illness in American society. This case and its context offer a window into the psychiatric and legal conversations within the deinstitutionalization movement. During a time when both psychiatry and the law were shifting in their professional claims and emphases, each side was captured by an idea of reform based on how they imagined the problems to be configured. Examining themes of place, authority, right to treatment, and dangerousness reveals the limitations of the reforms and the hardening of a narrative that limited state action to the elision of mental illness with dangerousness.

Book reviews:

  • Kristin A. Olbertson, The Dreadful Word: Speech Crime and Polite Gentlemen in Massachusetts (Jessica Lowe)
  • Mary Sarah Bilder, Female Genius: Eliza Harriot and George Washington at the Dawn of the Constitution (Rosemarie Zagarri)
Read more with OUP.


 

11 July 2022

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History LXII (2022), No. 2

 

(image source: OUP)

British Policy towards the Incorporation of the Baltic States into the USSR: A Dilemma of de facto and de jure Recognition (Evgeny Tikhonravov) (DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njac011)
Abstract:
Multiple viewpoints have been expressed regarding the British attitude towards the Soviet annexation of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania. The vast majority of writers maintain that the United Kingdom extended only de facto recognition to this incorporation. A small minority of commentators, however, hold otherwise and argue that Britain recognised the annexation de jure. To address this controversy, which has previously received almost no consideration, this article traces the development of the British policy towards the incorporation of the Baltic republics into the USSR, giving wide scope to the statements of the British government and to the views of Members of Parliament. Careful attention is also given to judicial practice. This legal and historical analysis helps to identify the meaning of de facto and de jure recognition used by Britain in the Baltic case, as well as clarifies a number of other relevant questions (for example, whether a territorial annexation may constitute a separate object of recognition, and whether a military occupant may be equated with a government recognised de facto). After determining the correct approach to this academic debate, the article suggests how its findings may contribute to studies contrasting the position of the UK with respect to the Baltic annexation with that of other countries.

The Judicial Failsafe: American Legal Colonialism in the Philippines (Timothy J Foley) (DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njac009)

Abstract:

This article evaluates the history of the Filipino judiciary during the period of US rule. It argues that colonial officials used the legal system to ensure US control over the islands by initiating a judicial transition, which contained a series of procedures guaranteeing US officials the power to overrule insular courts or legislatures. The judicial transition refers to the long-term transformation of Filipino law from the Spanish civil law system to an Anglo-American common law system through implementing a new code of civil procedure, changing the official language of legal proceedings to English, and importing US judges to the islands during the first part of the twentieth century. This transition masked a failsafe, which ensured that colonial administrators would retain power despite promises to cede control to the local population. Elements of this failsafe included maintaining a US majority on the Supreme Court of the Philippines, empowering the US Supreme Court to review and overturn decisions of the Filipino Supreme Court, and barring Filipino courts from ruling on matters of importance to the US government such as admiralty cases. The article contends that when taken together, this transition and failsafe constitute a strategy for the United States to maintain substantial control over the Philippines while still maintaining the facade of the benevolent colonizer.

Amnesty and the Limits of Transitional Justice in Brazil: The Case of Expelled Low-Ranking Soldiers, 1964–2014 (Marrilia Corrêa) (DOI 10.1093/ajlh/njac005)

Abstract:

This article shows the continuities of the military dictatorship and the limits of transitional justice in Brazil, arguing that the violations the military regime inflicted on certain groups persisted over three decades after democratization. Between 1964 and 1985 the military officers who took power strived to eliminate opposition to their rule from all sectors of society. Inside the armed forces, they expelled over 6,500 officers and soldiers from their ranks after accusing them of subversion. Between 1979 and 2014 the state created policies to start a democratic transition and address the civil and human rights violations perpetrated during military rule. It offered amnesty and reparations to individuals who had their political rights stripped from them after their names were published in Institutional Acts, legal instruments created by the military government to justify the political persecution of its opponents. Yet, transitional justice policies failed to address different mechanisms the dictatorship used to eliminate opposition, such as Air Force Decree 1,104, which determined that soldiers would be hired on four-year contracts. Masquerading it as a tool to regulate the organization of the Air Force, military officers used Decree 1,104 to expel soldiers whom the regime saw as politically subversives. This article shows how the transitional justice policies created in Brazil were insufficient to deal with the multiple ways the dictatorship punished its political opponents.

Book reviews:
  • Susan J. Pearson, The Birth Certificate: An American History (by Teal Arcadi)
  • Inge Van Hulle, Britain and International Law in West Africa (by Joyman Lee)
  • Anne Gray Fischer, The Streets Belong to Us: Sex, Race, and Police Power from Segregation to Gentrification (by Marie-Amélie George)
Read more here.

05 March 2021

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History (Vol. 60, Issue 4)

 

(Source: AJLH)

The American Journal of Legal History published its December 2020 issue several weeks ago.

Articles

The Anti-Republican Origins of the At-Will Doctrine

Lea VanderVelde 397

Capturing Profit from Disaster: The Assets Company Ltd and the Afterlife

of the City of Glasgow Bank

Sean O’Reilly 450

Where Did ‘Human Dignity’ Come from? Drafting the Preamble to the

Irish Constitution

Christopher McCrudden 485

From Disputation Hall to High Office: Swedish Students’ Legal

Dissertations at German and Dutch Universities in the Seventeenth and

Eighteenth Centuries

Marianne Vasara-Aaltonen 536

Book Reviews

The Historical Logics of Work Accident Law: Nate Holdren, Injury

Impoverished: Workplace Accidents, Capitalism, and the Law in the

Progressive Era

John Fabian Witt 564

Thomas J. McSweeney, Priests of the Law: Roman Law and the Making of

the Common Law’s First Professionals

John Hudson 574

Michael A. Schoeppner, Moral Contagion: Black Atlantic Sailors,

Citizenship, and Diplomacy in Antebellum America

Andrew Hammann 576

Emily Whewell, Law Across Imperial Borders: British Consuls and Colonial

Connections on China’s Western Frontiers, 1880–1943

Eric Schluessel 578

Leandra Ruth Zarnow, Battling Bella: The Protest Politics of Bella Abzug

Alison Lefkovitz 580

Mary Ziegler, Abortion and the Law in America: Roe v. Wade to the Present

Karissa Haugeberg 582

 

More info here

20 July 2020

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History (Vol. 60, Issue 2)



(Source: OUP)

The American Journal of Legal History has recently published its latest issue.

Articles
Reforming Criminal Justice in the Ottoman Empire: Police, Courts and Prisons in Rusçuk, 1839-1864
Mehmet Celik 109
Combatting Bias in the Criminal Courts of France, 1870s-1913
James Donovan 137
Political Judging and Judicial Restraint: The Case of Learned and Augustus Hand
Jak Allen 169
Law at a Critical Juncture: The US Army’s Command Responsibility Trials at Manila, 1945-1947
Jamie Fellows 192
White Subversion of Public School Desegregation in South Carolina, 1963-1970
Stephen Lowe 223
Book Reviews
Elizabeth Papp Kamali, Felony and the Guilty Mind in Medieval England
Sarah B. White 247
Anat Rosenberg, Liberalizing Contracts: Nineteenth Century Promises Through Literature, Law and History
Victoria Barnes 250

More info here

13 April 2020

JOURNAL: Law and History Review XXXVIII (2020), No. 1 (Feb)

(image source: Cambridge Core)

Select Intertwined Itineraries: Debt, Decolonization, and International Law in Post-World War II South-Asia (Kalyani Ramnath)
Abstract:
This Article brings a Tamil-speaking Chettiar widow and a Dutch scholar of international law - two seemingly disparate characters - together through a footnote. Set against the background of decolonizing South and Southeast Asia in the aftermath of World War Two, it follows the judgment in a little-known suit for recovery of debt, filed at a district-level civil court in Madras in British India, which escaped the attention of local legal practitioners, but made its way into an international law treatise compiled and written in Utrecht, twenty years later. Instead of using it to trace how South Asian judiciaries interpreted international law, the Article looks at why claims to international law were made by ordinary litigants like Chettiar women in everyday cases like debt settlements, and how they became “evidence” of state practice for international law. These intertwined itineraries of law, that take place against the Japanese occupation of Burma and the Dutch East Indies and the postwar reconstruction efforts in Rangoon, Madras and Batavia, show how jurisdictional claims made by ordinary litigants form an underappreciated archive for histories of international law. In talking about the creation and circulation of legal knowledges, this Article argues that this involves thinking about and writing from footnotes, postscripts and marginalia - and the lives that are intertwined in them.
Introduction: Why a History of Cultural Expertise? (Livia Holden)

The Indian Panchayat, Access to Knowledge and Criminal Prosecutions in Colonial Bombay, 1827–61 (James Jaffe)
Abstract:
Throughout the mofussil of the Bombay Presidency British judges and magistrates called upon panchayats, that is, caste or village councils, to help them administer justice. By the mid-nineteenth century, panchayats were being deployed by British justices not only to offer their advice to judges attempting to decide a case, but much more frequently to investigate crimes, including murder, assault, robbery, arson, forgery, rape, and property disputes. Moreover, the active participation of the panchayat in the administration of criminal law varied as much in form as in function. In different scenarios, the panchayat functioned as a coroner's court, a criminal investigation team, and a general witnessing agent for the courts. With very few exceptions, they almost always appear in a supporting role on the prosecution side of any case offering their opinions on the crime in question in written form. Judges, for their part, appear to have relied quite heavily upon these recommendations and there are very few instances in which the panchayat's opinions were either ignored or rejected. There thus developed a hybrid system of justice whereby judges and magistrates adapted, transformed, and incorporated the expertise and knowledge of the ‘customary’ panchayat to suit the needs of British governance and legal administration.
Cultural Expertise in Iran: From the Pahlavi Dynasty to Contemporary Diasporas (Soudabeh Marin)
Abstract:
This paper suggests the use of cultural expertise as encompassing concept that can account for the natural cultural competence developed in Iran. In earlier times, Zoroastrian law was first based on religious norms and the primary theological division between sins and offenses. Iranians had to adapt to different legal systems: customary law, religious law and secular law. Priests, jurists, judges, officials and translators were the main cultural “experts” and mediators between the people and the normative institutions. The introduction of imami legal theories and jurisprudence in the 16th century together with the reinforcement of the secular political power engaged Iran in a stabilized judicial context ruled by shiʿi scholars, qāzis and mujtahids. In 1919, as a consequence of the new French inspired Constitution, the Ministry of Justice, in order to train a new generation of judges, magistrates and justice personnel, set up a law school. Professors, who can be considered as cultural experts, contributed to the acculturation process initiated in the judicial system. Examples of his continuous struggle are recounted in Ostad Elahi's (1895-1974) memoirs, relating the difficulty Iranians had to accept the change, both cultural and psychological, initiated by the modernization and westernization program put into operation (1911-1935).
Historians at the Court: How Cultural Expertise in Qing Law Contributes to the Invention of Hong Kong “Chinese Customary Law” (Jérôme Bourgon)
Abstract:
This paper relies on the narrative of a renowned historian of Qing law from China mainland who has been called by Hong Kong High Court in 2007, to witness as an expert in “Chinese customary law.” At the opening of the trial, he recognized one well-known and estimated colleague from Taiwan in the expert engaged by the other party. During one week, these two legal historians called up a vast array of knowledge in Chinese history, culture, and law, to ensure the triumph of their party. The contest opposed the representatives of two branches of a same lineage who claimed their right to manage the lineage common wealth. As both were collaterals with dubious link with the original lineage, experts engaged in sophisticated arguments to make their cause prevail. Successively were adduced lineage registers the tabooing of fathers and emperors' personal name in the Chinese tradition, the degree of kinships as represented by “mourning charts” included in the Qing penal code. Even though it was “privately settled” before any judicial decision, this case raises questions on the very nature of “Chinese customary law”, and the role of “cultural expertise” at Common law in a Chinese environment.
Judging the Communist Past: Historians and Cultural Expertise in Polish Administrative Courts (Stanisław Burdziej)
Abstract:
Since 1989, cultural expertise has emerged as a crucial factor in navigating Poland's communist past. The use of cultural expertise provided by historians was institutionalized in 1999, when the Institute of National Remembrance was created and charged with prosecuting Nazi and communist crimes, as well as assisting with the belated decommunization. Expert historians are requested by courts and other institutions to provide opinions in cases ranging from alleged collaboration with communist secret services, withdrawal of veteran status bestowed to soldiers of communist military units fighting the Polish resistance movement, awarding compensation to victims of German concentration and labour camps, to changing names of places named after prominent Party activists. Using this expertise requires the courts to understand the intricacies of recent Polish history, such as the operational methodology and archival practices of communist secret services, or the complex interplay of motives to collaborate (or not) with foreign oppressors. In this paper, the new salience of historical expertise for the Polish courts is analysed within the framework of Honneth's (1995) ‘struggle for recognition’ and Haldemann's (2008) work on the symbolic role of courts in transitional justice contexts.
Expert Testimony in the Social Sciences: A Historical Overview of Contemporary Issues (Lawrence Rosen)
Abstract:
In this brief reconsideration of the roles experts may play in legal proceedings - and concentrating on the role of social scientists in particular - it may, therefore, be useful to revisit some very familiar issues and to address some seemingly peripheral matters that are nevertheless quite central to the way we think about the involvement of experts in legal cases. For purposes of introducing some of these issues it may be helpful to focus on three interrelated concerns: the ascertaining of expert qualifications, the role of evidentiary procedure, and the extra-judicial use of social information.
 Accounting for Colonial Legal Personhood: New Intersectional Histories from the British Empire (Antoinette Burton)
Abstract:
In this comment on the special issue, Burton situates the essays in the scholarship of 1980s and 1990s as well as very recent scholarship on age of consent laws. She notes patterns — including processes of abstraction and transnational circulation — that shaped the cases gathered here. She points as well to the stakes of prioritizing gender and conjugality in scholarship on legal imperial regimes of all kinds
Withholding Consent to Conjugal Relations within Child Marriages in Colonial India: Rukhmabai's Fight (Kanika Sharma)
Abstract:
Married at the age of eleven, Rukhmabai refused to go and live with her husband who had filed a suit for restitution of conjugal rights against her in 1884. This paper analyses the transplantation of the notion of restitution of conjugal rights into Hindu personal law in India at a time when child marriage was rife and there was no minimum age of marriage. Within this context Rukhmabai's case symbolises an important interjection in its attempt to posit lack of consent to an infant marriage as a defence against suits for restitution of conjugal rights. This marked a shift from female consent being understood as a question of physical maturity alone, to a claim of intelligent consent and the capacity to withhold such consent within an unconsummated marriage arranged in the girl's infancy. While analysing these notions of consent within colonial law the paper also closely scrutinises Rukhmabai's public writings to recover one of the earliest published Indian female views on the need for marital consent.
Intimate Violence in Colonial Bengal: A Death, a Trial and a Law, 1889–1891 (Tanika Sarkar)
Abstract:
Much excellent work has been done on the colonial Act X of 1891. Yet, three important contexts have largely gone missing. One is the framework of colonial Personal Laws where the practice of infantile marital cohabitation was embedded till it migrated to criminal laws. Unless we comprehend how the framework constrained judicial decisions and legal interventions, no single law can possibly make full sense. There were highly acrimonious public debates, too, especially in Bengal and Bombay Presidencies, that significantly shaped the Act. Legal reform in the field of gender, I argue, grew more out such debates than from colonial initiatives.
Cultures of Sex, Laws of Difference: Age of Consent Law and the Forging of a Fraternal Contract on the Margins of the Nineteenth-Century British Empire (Nafisa Essop Sheik)
Abstract:
In the British colony of Natal, laws governing sex for settlers were concerned with reproduction and sexual respectability, which were the grounds for imagining difference amongst imperial populations only recently assembled under colonial jurisdiction. Age of consent laws arose out of these contingencies rather than out of any concern with a liberal politics of social reform. Consequently, colonial age of consent laws governing white settlers bore only superficial resemblance to metropolitan legislative reforms such as age of consent laws. Instead, the Natal state's practices of law-making recognized three discrete and divergent moral economies of sex in the colonial laws governing white settler citizens, Native law which governed the lives of Africans and the consolidated body of laws governing Indian immigrants. In this young colony, not only did ‘age of consent’ laws have to be newly made, but they were conceived separately and contained by ‘colonial law’, ‘Native custom’ and ‘Indian custom’. The sexuality of young white woman was coded in colonial rape laws and used to draw lines of civilizational difference between settler citizens and their Others. For these others, relating sex to exceptional marriage customs excluded from legal codes of civilized common practice was how the state worked to assert difference.
The Problem of African Girlhood: Raising the Age of Consent in the Cape of Good Hope, 1893–1905 (Elizabeth Thornberry)
Abstract:
In 1893, legislation in the Cape Colony raised the age of consent to sexual intercourse from twelve to fourteen. Only twelve years later, however, did colonial administrators extend the law to the predominantly African districts in the eastern region of the colony. A reconstruction of the political debates surrounding the law, and its eventual extension, illuminates the relationship between understandings of childhood and race in the Cape. By the late 19th century, the comparison of Africans to children had become the governing metaphor for the “native question”; but this metaphor contained fundamental ambiguities. Debates over the age of consent forced Cape politicians to confront the racial and chronological boundaries of childhood innocence, and thus to articulate more precise theories of racial difference itself. Rural elites upheld a vision of hierarchy calibrated by wealth and social knowledge as well as race. Reformers sought to protect the innocence of white girls, in part to defend against racial degeneration, but disagreed over the inclusion of black girls. Meanwhile, even liberal social purity advocates hesitated to extend the law to the eastern districts, where “native law and custom” seemed not only to offer more protection but also to undermine claims of European superiority.
“Precocious Girls”: Age of Consent, Class and Family in Late Nineteenth-Century England (Laura Lammasniemi)
Abstract:
A fixed legal age of consent is used to determine when a person has the capacity to consent to sex yet in the late Victorian period the idea became a vehicle through which to address varied social concerns, from child prostitution and child sexual abuse to chastity and marriageability of working-class girls. This article argues that the Criminal Law Amendment Act (CLAA) 1885, the Act that raised the age of consent from thirteen to sixteen, and its application were driven by constructions of gender in conjunction with those of social class and working class family. The article firstly argues that CLAA 1885 and related campaigns reinforced class boundaries, and largely framed the working class family as absent, thereby, requiring the law to step in as a surrogate parent to protect the girl child. Secondly, the paper focuses on narratives emerging from the archives and argues that while narratives of capacity and protection in particular were key concepts behind reforms, the courts showed limited understanding of these terms. Instead, the courts focused on notions resistance, consent, and untrustworthiness of the victim, even when these concepts were not relevant to the proceedings due to victims' young age.
Vernacularizing Justice: Age of Consent and a Legal History of the British Empire (Ishita Pande)

Book reviews:
  • Johanna Ransmeier, Sold People: Traffickers and Family Life in Northern China, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2017. Pp. 408. $51.50 hardcover (ISBN 9780674971974 (Xiaoping Cong)
  • Jens Meierhenrich, The Remnants of the Rechtsstaat: An Ethnography of Nazi Law, New York: Oxford University Press, 2018. Pp. ix + 437. $61.00 hardcover (ISBN 9780198814412) (Peter C. Caldwell)
  • Philip Girard, Jim Phillips, and R. Blake Brown, A History of Law in Canada-Volume One-Beginnings to 1866, Toronto: The Osgoode Society for Canadian Legal History and University of Toronto Press, 2018. Pp xvii + 904. $120.00 (Canadian) hardcover (ISBN 9781487504632) (Jonathan Swainger)
  • Tamar Herzog, A Short History of European Law: The Last Two and a Half Millennia, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2018. Pp. vi + 289. Paperback $18.95 (ISBN 9780674237865) (Mia Korpiola)
Read the full issue on Cambridge Core.







16 December 2019

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History (Volume 59, Issue 4)


(Source: OUP Academic)

The American Journal of Legal History has just published its latest issue of the year. Here the contents:

Articles
A Counter-Culture of Law: Jurisprudential Change and the Intellectual
Origins of the Critical Legal Studies Movement
Juhana Saloja¨rvi 409
Railway Sparks: Technological Development and the Common Law
Mark L. Wilde 444
Machinations of the British Medical Association: Excluding Refugee
Doctors from Queensland’s Medical Profession, 1937–1942
Gabrielle Wolf 513
Book Review
David Harbecke, Modernisation Through Process: The Rise of the Court of
Chancery in the European Perspective
Lorenzo Maniscalco 542

More info here

10 September 2019

JOURNAL: American Journal of Legal History XIX (2019), No. 3 (Sep)

(image source: Cambridge Core)

‘To Stay the Murderer’s Hand and the Rapist’s Passions, and for the Safety and Security of Civil Society’: The Emergence of Racial Disparities in Capital Punishment in Jim Crow New Orleans  (Jeffrey S. Adler)
Abstract:
This essay examines capital punishment in New Orleans between 1920 and 1945. Building on a quantitative analysis of case-level data culled from police, court, and prison records, it explores the emergence of racial disparities in death-penalty sentencing and charts the increasing use of capital punishment as a mechanism of racial control. The paper focuses on four surprising and counter-intuitive patterns in the application of the death penalty. First, shifts in the use of capital punishment during this era bore no connection to patterns of violent crime. Second, changes in death-penalty sentencing were only loosely related to overall trends in homicide conviction. Third, and most surprising, Orleans Parish jurors, particularly during the 1920s, sent white killers to the gallows at a higher rate than African American killers. And fourth, the analysis of case-level records reveals dramatic shifts in death-penalty sentencing during the 1930s, particularly the development of a pronounced racial disparity in the application of capital punishment. Prosecutors also exploited the threat of capital charges to secure guilty pleas from African American suspects, and thus changes in death-penalty sentencing contributed to racial disparities in incarceration. In short, this micro-analysis helps to explain when and why the death penalty became a core component of Jim Crow criminal justice.
American Treatise Writers and the Nineteenth-Century Debate on Marriage with a Deceased Wife’s Sister in Transatlantic Context (Angela Fernandez)
Abstract:
The question whether a man could marry the sister of his deceased wife (or whether a woman could marry the brother of her deceased husband) sounds quaint to modern ears. Was this really ever thought to be incest? Yes, it was considered incest by affinity, that is, as a result of a relationship between the parties having been created by marriage, as opposed to incest by consanguinity caused by a blood relationship. Incest by affinity had been prohibited under canon law already long before the time of King Henry VIII, with whose marriages (and their annulments) it was closely associated.1 The status of affinity incest marriages created much vexation in...
The Development of the ‘Modern’ Criminal Law of Evidence in English Law and in France, Germany and the Netherlands: 1750–1900
Abstract:
In this article a comparative historical analysis is given of the development of the criminal law of evidence between 1750 and 1870 in, on the one hand, English law and, on the other hand, in the continental jurisdictions of France, Germany and the Netherlands. The main argument is that, although there were significant differences, there were also important similarities in the development of the criminal law of evidence among these jurisdictions that so far have largely gone unnoticed. The article focuses on the ideas underlying the reform of the criminal law of evidence. It will be argued that there were in particular two important ideological changes in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries that shaped the reform of the criminal law of evidence. For lack of a better term, these developments are called the ‘political-constitutional discourse’ and the ‘epistemological discourse’. The epistemological change consisted of the adoption of a probabilistic conception of the certainty that was required in criminal cases. The term ‘political-constitutional discourse’ is meant to designate the general process of rethinking the relationship between the state and its citizens that took place between the seventeenth and nineteenth centuries.
 Book reviews:

  •  Martha S. Jones, Birthright Citizens: A History of Race and Rights in Antebellum America  (Kyle G. Volk)
  •  Whitman, James Q. Hitler’s American Model: The United States and the Making of Nazi Race Law  (Joseph A. Ross)
  •  Elizabeth Stordeur Pryor, Colored Travelers: Mobility and the Fight for Citizenship before the Civil War (Kristin O'Brassill-Kulfan)
(read more on Cambridge Core)


23 April 2019

CALL FOR APPLICATIONS: New co-Editor for the American Journal of Legal History


(Source: OUP)

The American Journal of Legal History is recruiting a new co-editor, with special expertise in the legal history of the United States. Here the call:

Oxford University Press (OUP) is seeking to recruit a new co-Editor for the American Journal of Legal History (AJLH) with special expertise in the legal history of the United States. Professor Al Brophy, who currently co-edits the AJLH with Professor Stefan Vogenauer, is planning to step down due to ongoing health issues. Professor Brophy has been a key figure in the successful relaunch of the journal after it joined forces with OUP. The publishers are now seeking to appoint his successor for an initial term of three years, with effect from 1 September 2019.

About the AJLH

The AJLH was founded in 1957 and was the first English-language periodical in the field. It was relaunched as an OUP publication at the beginning of 2016 with new editors, Professors Al Brophy (University of Alabama School of Law, Tuscaloosa) and Stefan Vogenauer (Max Planck Institute for European Legal History, Frankfurt).

The new AJLH aims to publish outstanding scholarship on all facets and periods of legal history. While retaining its focus on American legal history, it accommodates the enormous broadening of the intellectual horizon of the discipline over the past decade and is particularly interested in contributions of a comparative, international or transnational nature. Book reviews are a regular feature. The new AJLH is a quarterly, peer-reviewed journal. For more information please visit the journal website.

AJLH co-Editor Roles and Responsibilities

The AJLH team currently consists of two co-Editors (one with a US focus and one with a focus on the rest of the world, particularly Europe), two Book Review Editors (again, one with a focus on the US and one with a focus on the rest of the world), a Managing Editor, and an Associate Editor. The editorial office is based at the Max Planck Institute in Frankfurt.

AJLH articles are submitted online via Scholar One. After an initial screen by the Managing Editor and the Associate Editor, the co-Editors read the submissions in their respective fields of geographical expertise and agree which should go forward through the peer review process. Each article is usually reviewed by two anonymous independent reviewers who are experts in the field. The co-Editors then communicate to make the final decision on whether the article should be accepted. Once an article is accepted, it goes through a footnote check, a copy editing and language editing process in Frankfurt. It is then sent to OUP. At this point, the co-Editors take part in page proof corrections.

The Editors are responsible for the following, in association with the Publisher:

  • Setting the editorial direction of the journal
  • Obtaining high quality content for the journal and delivering it to the Publisher on schedule
  • Coordinating the peer review process and supervising the proof correction process
  • Promoting the journal to authors and subscribers
  • Meeting with the Publisher, either in person or via phone/Skype, at least once per year
Candidates will be leaders in the field of US legal history, with significant experience of publishing in legal history, ideally with experience of editing a journal or similar publication.

Appointment procedure

We will begin reviewing applications on June 1, and continue until the position is filled. Interested parties are invited to apply with a CV and a statement (no more than two pages) detailing their interest in the post and their relevant experience. Please email Grace Ranola for more information, or to make a formal application.

Informal enquiries may also be directed to 
Stefan Vogenauer. Applicants should expect to be interviewed by both OUP and the current editor, via telephone or Skype if need be, so please supply relevant contact information.

More information with OUP