Ius Commune Workshop on Comparative Legal History 2024
Ius Commune in the Making:
Manifestations of Nature in Law
The 28th Ius Commune Conference will take place in Utrecht (28-29 November 2024), and a Workshop will be devoted to “Manifestations of Nature in Law.”
The workshops on “Comparative Legal History – Ius Commune in the Making” aim to reveal and understand the nature and effects of various legal formants in the development of law. Indeed, forces of legal formants are too often lost or hidden beneath a superficies of commonalities. History is a living laboratory. In the past, we explored the role of legal actors (2014), legal sources (2016), force of local laws (2017), methods and dynamics of law (2018), networks (2019), paradigmatic shifts (2020), great debates in the history of law (2021), and the concept of innovation in law (2023).
Nature rises prominently in law, especially these days. It manifests itself in the shape of climate, environment, ecology, biodiversity, protection of species, and much more, in legislation and case law (e.g. ECHR 9 April 2024). Scholarly debate engages in this topic, in which empirical and scientific methodologies contribute to a highly detailed legal fabric, with political arena and populus highly divided. Nature and its manifestations are positioned as an object of normative arrangement of humans. Geographic areas are as natural objects attributed to humans and juristic persons, or are themselves constructed as subjects. Human actions in these natural domains are regulated in the perspective of sustainability. Nature is, so to speak, still taken in legal custody, as a preconceived and rather impoverished image of reality. We do have to use our senses more and to fuel law through our hearts and minds.
History offers images of nature (φύσις) and its manifestations in law (νόμος), a landscape of so many formants. Traditionally nature is considered the prime source of all things, the Rerum Magna Parens. Natural law coexists with consensual law (both religious and secular), offering sound principles, universal and unchangeable, based on rational capabilities. Nature can be found in concepts and system, in principles and reasoning, in various times and places, through its existence in foundational texts, also beyond law. Examples include, in Roman law, the concept of person, being endowed by nature with freedom (Inst.1.3.1). Grotius influentially qualified things as “whatever is external to man and in any way useful to man” (Inleidinge, 2.1.3). The centrality of the person and its subjective rights are manifest, at least since early modern times. Not just natures’ existence in foundational scholarly texts, but also in more mundane, but often poetical texts of custom, case law, even legislation, where nature may appear in its wild variety. Montesquieu was not the first to take climate and environment seriously in law (L’Esprit des Lois, ch 14-18). A very cold climate sets the scene, makes the condition for a Frisian widow to sell or pledge her husband’s heritage, in the interest of the fatherless child (2nd Frisian londriucht). Nor is it just customary or learned law in the western tradition. The step towards anthropology is small – all animals have emotional intelligence similar to that of humans, noted Hoebel (The Law of Primitive Man, 69), and it needs not even to be written nor to be law. The earth may not even exist, according to Chatwin “until [one] could see and sing it – just as in the Dreamtime, the country had not existed until the Ancestors sang it” (Schreiner, According to Aboriginal Law, 66). Observation and understanding are key. Surely, there is more between Tohu wa-bohu and Whanganui’s personality.
Senior researchers and PhD candidates are invited to submit an abstract of a paper related to the above-mentioned theme. Abstracts (max. 400 words) should be sent to Agustín Parise (agustin.parise@maastrichtuniversity.nl) no later than 15 July 2024. Shortly after that, the authors will be informed whether their papers are selected for a presentation during the Workshop. All contributions should be in English. Co-authored papers will be also considered. The organizing committee will give preference to early-career researchers when facing submissions of similar quality.
Researchers from within and outside the Ius Commune Research School will be eligible to present abstracts. Please also forward this call to colleagues who might be interested.
Should you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact a member of the organizing committee,
Harry Dondorp (j.h.dondorp@vu.nl)
Wouter Druwé (wouter.druwe@kuleuven.be)
Michael Milo (j.m.milo@uu.nl)
Pim Oosterhuis (janwillem.oosterhuis@maastrichtuniversity.nl)
Agustín Parise (agustin.parise@maastrichtuniversity.nl)
No comments:
Post a Comment