BOOK: Laura KALMAN, FDR's Gambit The Court Packing Fight and the Rise of Legal Liberalism (Oxford: University Press, 2022). ISBN: 9780197539293, pp. 440, £22.99

 

(Source: OUP)

ABOUT THE BOOK

In the last past few years, liberals concerned about the prospect of long-term conservative dominance of the federal courts have revived an idea that famously crashed and burned in the 1930s: court packing. Not surprisingly, today's court packing advocates have run into a wall of opposition, with most citing the 1930s episode as one FDR's greatest failures. In early 1937, Roosevelt-fresh off a landslide victory-stunned the country when he proposed a plan to expand the size of the court by up to six justices. Today, that scheme is generally seen as an act of hubris-an instance where FDR failed to read Congress and the public properly.

In FDR's Gambit, the eminent legal historian Laura Kalman challenges the conventional wisdom by telling the story as it unfolded, without the distortions of hindsight. Indeed, while scholars have portrayed the Court Bill as the ill-fated brainchild of a hubristic President made overbold by victory, Kalman argues to the contrary that acumen, not arrogance, accounted for Roosevelt's actions. Far from erring tragically from the beginning, FDR came very close to getting additional justices, and the Court itself changed course. As Kalman shows, the episode suggests that proposing a change in the Court might give the justices reason to consider whether their present course is endangering the institution and its vital role in a liberal democracy.

Based on extensive archival research, FDR's Gambit offers a novel perspective on the long-term effects of court packing's failure, as a legacy that remains with us today. Whether or not it is the right remedy for today's troubles, Kalman argues that court packing does not deserve to be recalled as one fated for failure in 1937.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Laura Kalman is Distinguished Research Professor of History at the University of California, Santa Barbara, a member of the California Bar, and Past President of the American Society for Legal History. She is the author of The Long Reach of the Sixties: LBJ, Nixon, and the Making of the Contemporary Supreme Court; Right Star Rising: A New Politics, 1974-1980; Yale Law School and the Sixties: Revolt and Reverberations; The Strange Career of Legal Liberalism; Abe Fortas: A Biography; and Legal Realism at Yale, 1927-1960.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Acknowledgments

Preface Court Packing as History and Memory

1. Roosevelt v. "The Nine Old Men": March 1933-February 1936

2. Victory-and Its Fruits: April 6-December 26, 1936

3. Bright Prospects, Bold Opposition: January 1-March 3, 1937

4. A Change in Tune at the White House—and at the Court?: March 4-April 11, 1937

5. "Talk of Compromise...Heard Everywhere": April 12-May 25, 1937

6. "Prestige": May 18, 1937-November 8, 1938

7. Afterlife: 1937-2021

Afterword About those "later historians": Historians, Political Scientists, and Law Professors Confront "1937"

Notes

Index

More information with the publisher.